Mayweather vs. Pavlik or JMM vs. Mayweather. Equally (un)fair?

[K-Nan]

Mayweather has had more than half of his fights at 130. Pavlik is a full blown Middleweight who has been as high as 168. Mayweather didn't even fill out SWW when he fought there. Marquez is currently coming in above 140, and the fight is contracted to be slightly above 140. You tell me which fight is fair.

Stop smoking crack.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Any fighter would sign a fight for millions of dollars.

Pavlik at 158 is the same catchweight. Same difference.

Exactly. I presented this same situation, only it was Abraham instead of Kelly,


and this was the response of the Floyd brigade,

[larry x]

in your dreams.
Floyd lost to Jose Luis Castillo.
Pavlik would knock him out in 2 rounds!

floyds never lost *******..39-0..floyd boxes pavlik's ears off

[fallenloki]

Margarito called out Floyd too,

but since he was a welterweight, and bigger,

Floyd retired.

Stop saying Floyd came back to fight Marquez because he called him out.

The most practical situation for Floyd presented itself, and he took it.

Why would he be scared of Margarito? Hasn't he proven to be just a chin stumbling forward? He'd beat him like he did Corrales.

The fact is the division is hot right now, so I hope that by year's end he takes a mega fight with Pac or Cotto to shut most on this forum up.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Mayweather has had more than half of his fights at 130. Pavlik is a full blown Middleweight who has been as high as 168. Mayweather didn't even fill out SWW when he fought there. Marquez is currently coming in above 140, and the fight is contracted to be slightly above 140. You tell me which fight is fair.

Stop smoking crack.

Isn't the point of "pound for pound", being able to beat those who are bigger than you as well as smaller?


The majority of Floyds opponents have been smaller.

Why is asking him to fight someone bigger out of the question?

[DE100]

This is why the threads on here are so bad, even posters with close to 10,000 post dont know that they are talking about.

[Abstraction]

Mayweather v Marquez seems ******, but Mayweather been out nearly 2 years.

******, but can happen.

Mayweather v Pavlik is just dumb

Seriously, getting sick of all the pathetic "fans" and "haters". This "Forum" is full of kids

[larry x]

This is why the threads on here are so bad, even posters with close to 10,000 post dont know that they are talking about.

all you have to do is make a negative thread about floyd and watch how people flock to it...sad,sad,sad

[fallenloki]

in your dreams.
Floyd lost to Jose Luis Castillo.
Pavlik would knock him out in 2 rounds!

No... and no.

Dude. Pavlik couldn't even see where a much slower and older Bernard Hopkins was at. Mayweather would humiliate him.

[BattlingNelson]

Mayweather has had more than half of his fights at 130. Pavlik is a full blown Middleweight who has been as high as 168. Mayweather didn't even fill out SWW when he fought there. Marquez is currently coming in above 140, and the fight is contracted to be slightly above 140. You tell me which fight is fair.

Stop smoking crack.

Plenty of fighters grow out of their weightcalss. It doesn't matter which class they fought in 5 years ago. What matters is what weight class you can say they fight in today. Floyd is a welterweight. 2 weightclasses below you have JMM. 2 weightclasses above you have Pavlik.