Who's been more impressive The Punisher or Juanma Lopez?

[Fighting Champ]

Whos been more impressive Paul Williams or Juan Manuel lopez?

Two young stars both recently putting a beat down on older, but well recognized name fighters.
I know this might bring a war of arguments. So keep it clean and defend yourselves at all time.




Peace

[larry x]

lopez...williams is all hype
his last 3 fights
1-andy kolle-lol
2-40 year old verno phillips
3-37 year old coming off of a 2 year layoff winky

[Kevin Jesus]

You should make a poll.

But let me try to break it down

Paul Williams(Age 27) notable wins:
Antonio Margarito, Carlos Quintana, Verno Phillips, Winky Wright
notable loses: Carlos Quintana


Juanma Lopez(Age 25) notable wins:
Ponce De Leon, Penalosa
Notable loses: N/A


They can't be compared yet, Williams is far in front despite the loss.

[Fox McCloud]

lopez...williams is all hype
his last 3 fights
1-andy kolle-lol
2-40 year old verno phillips
3-37 year old coming off of a 2 year layoff winky

Lopez's last 3 fights:

Penalosa - Old and not that great to begin with.
Medina - Straight ****ing bum with a bull**** record.
Figueroa - Who? He was like 30-6 and had lost against some good fighters, and some not so good fighters.

This sounds weird coming from a huge Lopez fan, but... I have to admit, Williams has been blowing me away with his last few fights... ESPECIALLY the Phillips fight.

Also, a win over Margarito is probably more impressive than a win over Daniel Ponce de Leon, which is a matchup of their best wins.

[Burner]

Williams has fought the better comp...........

And is the better fighter......

Junama hasne fought his "Margarito fight yet.....you know the number 1 ranked guy.

[Burner]

lopez...williams is all hype
his last 3 fights
1-andy kolle-lol
2-40 year old verno phillips
3-37 year old coming off of a 2 year layoff winky

Look my Mafia brother...you cant fault Williams for his resume when NO ONE wants to fight him...

Shane Mosley, The number 1 WW had this to say:::

"Ill fight anyone except him".

"Our styles dont match up well"

That says it all.

His last 3 fights shouldve been......ALL WINS VS.

1. Cintron by KO
2. Cotto by KO
3. Mosley by KO

[Fox McCloud]

Williams has fought the better comp...........

And is the better fighter......

Junama hasne fought his "Margarito fight yet.....you know the number 1 ranked guy.

I don't know how you can say that Williams is the better fighter...

I mean, other than lack of insanely good competition, what flaws have you seen with Lopez? In his fights that I've seen, he's looked pretty close to perfect.

Williams has shown some defensive lapses... They aren't a big deal, because he makes up for them with his workrate and chin, but...

Idk, I just don't know how someone can be so sure fire certain that someone is better than a guy who hasn't shown any flaws yet.

[Kevin Jesus]

Lopez's last 3 fights:

Penalosa - Old and not that great to begin with.
Medina - Straight ****ing bum with a bull**** record.
Figueroa - Who? He was like 30-6 and had lost against some good fighters, and some not so good fighters.

This sounds weird coming from a huge Lopez fan, but... I have to admit, Williams has been blowing me away with his last few fights... ESPECIALLY the Phillips fight.

Also, a win over Margarito is probably more impressive than a win over Daniel Ponce de Leon, which is a matchup of their best wins.

Yeah, Juanma looks like he will be a great fighter(against other great fighters) but he's young and coming up slow like he's supposed to. At age 25, Paul fought the most feared fighter and beat him convincingly. I can't wait to see Juanma against the top dogs too, he's gonna be a real good fighter Imo.

[Pugilistic™]

I'm a Juanma fan but i rate Williams wins recently over Juanma's.

His performance againt Winky was very impressive.

Winky may of had the long layoff and is past his best but his timing still seemed to be there and he was doing good in a few rounds. It was simply Williams style being all wrong for Wright. He clearly won using his superior reach and workrate.

His knockout over Quintana in the rematch was also impressive. Quintana proved he was tough against Cotto by taking his best shots for 5 rounds. Williams laid him out in 1.

Juanma's display of power was impressive against De leon but Leon is a very limited fighter.

His performance against Penalosa was impressive but Penalosa has never been a good fighter.

I feel Juanma has more potential, is the better fighter overall and will have the better career.

[rican4life]

well iam a juanma lopez fan and juanma is sturggling to get people to fight him first of all so pual william has some very good wins under his belt, but when juanma get more people to fight him he will be right there. love juanma but pual williams has fought the tuffer fighter one reason people are will to fight him on the other hand juanma it has been tuff for him to get people that want to fight him.. I want el indio vs pual williams one more time you up for it paul williams ????