If Jmm were to beat pbf would he be p4p number 1 in your eyes if...

[xxjace]

If hatton beats pacman and jmm beats pbf...I know alot of people have this as a big if but what if...would you consider Jmm p4p #1.

Think about it...

Jmm last 3 fights

went the distance with pacman(plus some people thought he won)
ko'd Casamoyer
stopped Juan Diaz

If he were to beat pbf would you say it was pbf's ring rust??? or would it be that jmm was just better than pbf??? Curios on peoples opinions on this..

Or would Hatton be p4p #1?? I think Hatton is at least #2 or 3 if he beats pacman??

[Scott9945]

If Marquez pulls off a clean win over Floyd, he would have to be considered #1 P4P.

[S.G.]

of course it's JMM

Floyd is the biggest scalp anyone can get at the moment

[xxjace]

I say yes..also because I think he has a great chance of beating pbf just because pbf has been out of the ring so long..If pbf was still active I might say different..Does pbf get the edge because he's pbf? Or does the active Marquez that has been doing this non stop get the spot? Remember guys this is all opinionated..so dont diss me for my comments just my opinion..thanks

[MANGLER]

If Pac loses JMM becomes #1 by default. He really solidifies it if he beats Mr boat buyer, but he won't.

[xxjace]

I love Hatton more than most... he is my favorite current fighter..but I'm not sure if he is p4p #1 if he beats pac will Marquez so close..If it wasnt for JMM Hatton would be easily I think.

[a-raines21]

anybody who beats floyd would be p4p #1 in my eyes

[The Gambler1981]

He would have to get real consideration, I personally think he would be. Would be a crazy accomplishment for him if hse can find a way to do it (I doubt he can but it is boxing after all so who knows)

[xxjace]

If Pac loses JMM becomes #1 by default. He really solidifies it if he beats Mr boat buyer, but he won't.

I agree thats true ..

[street bully]

If Manny destroys Hatton, and JMM barley gets by Pbf with a win, I would have JMM as p4p number one.