If Jmm were to beat pbf would he be p4p number 1 in your eyes if...

[S.G.]

c'mon man... hatton is a tougher fight than diaz... hatton is more physical and stronger and has more punching power than juan diaz.

casamayor is as shot as dlh.

beating floyd would be great for jmm, but pac still has 2 victories over jmm.

pac's still #1 even if jmm beats floyd.

Casamayor was past his best days, sure

but as shot as De La Hoya? That's harsh man. We're talking Castillo levels of shotness when he fought Hatton. Barrera when he fought Khan. The guy was a corpse

[The Gambler1981]

Another interesting question slightly different then this is. How would you rate JMM compared to Barrera and Morales should he beat Mayweather?

[Pullcounter]

Casamayor was past his best days, sure

but as shot as De La Hoya? That's harsh man. We're talking Castillo levels of shotness when he fought Hatton. Barrera when he fought Khan. The guy was a corpse

no it's not. DLH was both dehydrated and shot, while casamayor was just shot.

castillo was shot and unmotivated for hatton.

mab isn't as shot as casamayor or castillo, although i don't hink he'd ever beat khan, just cause khan is a huge cat with quick hands.

Another interesting question slightly different then this is. How would you rate JMM compared to Barrera and Morales should he beat Mayweather?

if jmm beat floyd, then you'd have to put him above mab and morales