Whats the bigger accomplishment? Calzaghe or Floyd

[ACHlLLES]

Calzaghe moves up in weight to fight the best light heavy Hopkins or Having Ricky Hatton move up to 147 to fight him and destroy him at a weight class he has always looked horrible at. People like to use hopkins age as an excuse, yet Hopkins has been beating good/great fighters even at his old age.

And its not like Calzaghe was a spring chicken either.

[savorduhflavor]

The Hopkins win was better, but you can't even put Calzaghe's career and Floyd's career in the same sentence.

[ACHlLLES]

The Hopkins win was better, but you can't even put Calzaghe's career and Floyd's career in the same sentence.

I just did, and I won.

[MANGLER]

Damn Mr boat buyer is popular around here. Bhop>Hatton, so that win is a bigger accomplishment. But Joe C didn't really defeat Bhop, he just edged a SD. Mr boat buyer KO'd Hatton. Joe over Bhop is a bigger accomplishment, Mr boat buyer over Hatton was a better performance.

[JPRINCEOFBOXING]

Mayweather beating hatton is not a accomplishment cause hatton was not fighting in his normal or natural weight class so i vote for calzaghe

[Klitschko2011]

Calzaghe moving up to 175 to clearly beat, **** **** and humuliate #1 LHW Hopkins is definitely the bigger accomplishment.

[BmoreBrawler]

In all fairness, you should be comparing Fraud moving up to fight an old Oscar as comparable to Calzaghe moving up to fight an old Bhop. I had Oscar and Bhop winning both of those fights so...at least Calzaghe was aggressive and Bhop beat some ppl afterwards, so I'll give the nudge to Calzaghe.

[F l i c k e r]

Calzaghe has the better accomplishment in terms of your question.


Mayweather has a way better resume/legacy.

[savorduhflavor]

I just did, and I won.

You put compared a single win. Not their careers.

[krazyx19]

Of course Calzaghe's best win on his 15 year resume is better than a win that Mayweather rarely even gets credit for nowadays.