What If J.Clottey didnt broke his hand against Margarito would he win or lose?? POLL

[LA BAD BOY]

would Joshua Clottey win or lose if he didnt broke his hand in 5 round??

[El Dominicano]

would Joshua Clottey win or lose if he didnt broke his hand in 5 round??

He would have won, he was whoppin that ass before it happend. Margarito was beating up on a one-handed fighter and Clottey showed how much heart he had

[Pullcounter]

would Joshua Clottey win or lose if he didnt broke his hand in 5 round??

i wanna say yes, but we won't know unless they rematch

[winac]

He did break his hand

[BoriKua305]

his hand wasn't broken.

Comments

* Margarito suffered from a severe sprained ankle only a week before the bout, and also had problems with his left shoulder as reported days before the fight.
* Clottey suffered an injured left hand in round four, probably while landing a left uppercut. He immediately went into retreat and told his corner at the break.
* Showtime reported this live, explaining why Clottey proceded to lose rounds five through eleven on all three official scorecards.
* Clottey later admitted his hand was not broken as initially reported.
* Data Boxing reported blows: Margarito 356/972 37%, Clottey 210/468 45%. Clottey led in controls 89, mostly defensive, to Margarito's 70, usually attacking. In the very busy 133 Events Per Round( Attempts + Controls), Margarito had a 65-35% advantage, due to his workman like approach.

[Sin City]

He would have won, he was whoppin that ass before it happend. Margarito was beating up on a one-handed fighter and Clottey showed how much heart he had

Margarito usually takes 4 rounds to get going so who knows..

btw, Clottey's hand was never broken.
For all we know he could have used it as an excuse.

[winac]

Cotto is just going to have to fight Margarito again. Why fight a man who has already lost to the man who beat you?

[BoriKua305]

Cotto is just going to have to fight Margarito again. Why fight a man who has already lost to the man who beat you?

because margacheato is suspended he wants to fight a live welterweight. Also clottey is also the third best welteweight behind cotto and mosley

[larry x]

i think he wouldve won

[PRPOWERPUNCHES]

Cotto is just going to have to fight Margarito again. Why fight a man who has already lost to the man who beat you?

What a ****** question.