All Time Greatest. Floyd or Manny?

[DarchinyFAN]

Floyds lower weight class resume is better then Mannys....

Hes also about to beat JMM....and he already beat Hatton and Oscar two gus Mannys fought....and when the time comes He wil KO Manny.

So its Floyd.

I thought for sure you'd pick Manny..... seriously, you should say Manny sometime, just to see if people even notice....

[Ido]

Ok, then my answer is Floyd. He is undefeated, his skills are on a higher level than pacquiaos. Floyd KO:d hatton, Paquiao will be KO:d by Hatton.

I think Manny legacy is going to be widely remembered more so then Floyds. But mostly due to the fact, he came up in a loaded division with quality fighters. Then you have his decisive victory over DLH.

[Burner]

I thought for sure you'd pick Manny..... seriously, you should say Manny sometime, just to see if people even notice....

Do you have any rebuttal to the facts I presented.

Floyds lower weight resume is better then Mannys.
Floyd already beat Hatton and Oscar at 154.
Floyd is about to KO JMM whos Mannys best win.
Then when the time comes hell beat the shyt out of Manny and KO him.


If not then hush.

[FasTHarD]

Pacquiao's resume >>> Mayweather...
So no doubt Manny will be remembered than Floyd.
Manny will be remembered as a fighter who knocked people from 106-147 in the pros.
And will be remembered as the best p4p king ever.

[FasTHarD]

Do you have any rebuttal to the facts I presented.

Floyds lower weight resume is better then Mannys.
Floyd already beat Hatton and Oscar at 154.
Floyd is about to KO JMM whos Mannys best win.
Then when the time comes hell beat the shyt out of Manny and KO him.


If not then hush.

Pacs best wins came from ATG's not HOF like JMM.
I mean Morales, Barrera,Delahoya...

Pac resume in the higher weight >>> Floyds lower weights resume.

[Pullcounter]

Between the two, who will be remembered as the ATG?

i gotta go with pac... moving from 106-140 is pretty impressive

[-EX-]

I think Manny legacy is going to be widely remembered more so then Floyds. But mostly due to the fact, he came up in a loaded division with quality fighters. Then you have his decisive victory over DLH.

That was a decent win at best. His wins over Marquez, Morales, and Barrera are way more impressive. I don't give him much credit for beating a zombie version of Oscar.

[DarchinyFAN]

Do you have any rebuttal to the facts I presented.

Floyds lower weight resume is better then Mannys.
Floyd already beat Hatton and Oscar at 154.
Floyd is about to KO JMM whos Mannys best win.
Then when the time comes hell beat the shyt out of Manny and KO him.


If not then hush.

No I was making a joke (way to catch it).

Unlike alot of people on here, I don't feel the need to answer this question for the 1000th time, just because some turnip of a TS can't come up with an original idea.

Just to humor you though, I place them around the same level all time, though they have done it in different ways. Manny has scrapped his way up, and despite what his critics say has beaten a better collection of guys in their primes and at their best weights, but he has lost a few on the way, and has barely made it by some others. Floyd's resume is slightly less IMO, but he has shown a technical mastery over all his opponents (save the first Castillo fight [for the record I had FM winning it]) that allows me to extrapolate his career out and confidently say he would likely defeat other great opponents in the divisions he went through had he chosen to face them.

[Bushbaby]

Manny is the man,he has won great fights,he isnt as skilled as floyd,but he makes due with his capabilities,floyd could have been the best fighter,if he beat the best and left no?????,but he chose the easy road!!!!

Say what u like,but Manny went to fight Oscar at 147,it does not matter how shot Oscar was,no one expected Manny to destroy him like he did!!Floyds biggest win was against Chico,everything else was cherrypicked!!!

[Burner]

No I was making a joke (way to catch it).

Unlike alot of people on here, I don't feel the need to answer this question for the 1000th time, just because some turnip of a TS can't come up with an original idea.

Just to humor you though, I place them around the same level all time, though they have done it in different ways. Manny has scrapped his way up, and despite what his critics say has beaten a better collection of guys in their primes and at their best weights, but he has lost a few on the way, and has barely made it by some others. Floyd's resume is slightly less IMO, but he has shown a technical mastery over all his opponents (save the first Castillo fight [for the record I had FM winning it]) that allows me to extrapolate his career out and confidently say he would likely defeat other great opponents in the divisions he went through had he chosen to face them.

Who wins head to head?

Mayweather vs. Pacman