If JMM was a natural WW would Floyd have taken this fight?

[PoetryInMotion]

he would have taken him if he was a ****ing jr middle you hater, as long as he is p4p

Says the alt. It's funny when Floyd fans have to login under alts to evenout the poll. I by no means am a Floyd hater, he gots tons of skills, but I dont pretend that he displays those skills against the fighters he should be fighting.

[DLT]

If JMM was #2 p4p(since some idiot thinks thats the reason Floyd took the fight), had been fighting like he's fighting and doing what he's been doin except he was doing it at WW. Would Floyd have took the fight?

Dude, thats the same exaxtct thing Ive been saying in Floyds favor at WW for years. Do you think Margarito, Cotto, Mosley, or any of those guys would hold Floyd's joke if Floyd was a natural WW who came into the ring at 162 pounds like them? He would destroy all of trhem but none of them fear him because he comes in at 148 and all of them will have 14-22 pounds on him in the ring. I dont hear any of you ever complaing about that. Everything you guys have been saying about JMM is the same thing that Ive been saying about Floyd fo years but no one cared then and they still dont now. How come you ccry about this but yet you think its so fair for Floyd to have to fight all the WW's who come in between162-170 pounds while he only comes in at 148. How is that fair? You never say anything and instead you call him a punk for not jumping to fight them, like he's a real WW. You guys still try to play him as a real WW even though he's fighting at the same weight on fight night that Pac has been doing since 130

[Bhopreign]

Its about what weight you fight best at, Floyd presumably fights best at 135-140, we dont know what weight is best for Marquez since we havent seen him at 140. This fight becomes more credible due to the fact that Floyd has looked better 140 and below and the fact that he has been off a year and a half.

[Guest]

Floyd's 2 million plus PPV buyers need to get on the scene and vote.

He's getting shellacked in this poll.

[VaBoriKua 2.0]

a thread full of haters trying to answer a question that nobody KNOWS the answer to....... you all sound like ****in ******s....... if floyd were to ko cotto today, u all would say, now he has to fight mosley, and so on and so forth........

no cause its the truth he doesnt fight welterweights. He only fights blown up jww or bnlown up light weights or old past primed fighters

[Horus]

Is Floyd a natural welterweight?

of course not...
when he goes into the hof he will go in as a Super Featherweight.
He spent 70% of his career there.

Floyd is not a natural welterweight compared to the rest of the fighters in the welterweight division.

I say Floyd is not a true welterweight COMPARED to the rest of the fighters in the welterweight division.

The reason that weight classes exist at all is to ensure a fair fight. Fair and safe competition begins with the requirement that the two men facing each other are the same size in terms of weight.


At Welterweight Floyd fights at a Physical Disadvantage every fight, because he is coming in at the welterweight limit and other fighters are coming in as Middleweights...!

I am pretty sure if Floyd wanted to fight middleweights, he would rather fight for a middleweight title rather than a welterweight title.

At Welterweight.
Floyd is suppose to be fighting 147 pound fighters not 165 pounds Fighters posing as 147 pound fighters....


But People say all he has to fight a real WW and nobody else..!!!
Like Floyd comes in at 160 like every other fighter does at Welterweight.

FLOYD IS NOT A NATURAL WELTERWEIGHT COMPARED TO OTHER WELTERWEIGHTS.

If you are truly interested in Welterweights (147 pounders) fighting welterweights...then you should be disgusted at the fact that all the supposedly Welterweights in the WW division all fight around 160 when the fight starts. when the limit they should be at is 147.


When people say Floyd needs to beat a real WW and stop fighting on smaller guys?

They say that like Floyd 1st or 2nd division was WW and he has been fighting Small guys his whole Career....

Context
The WW Division

Cotto's: 2nd Division
Margarito's: 2nd Division
Shane Mosley: 3rd Division
Andre Berto: 2nd Division (1st:160)
Joshua Clottey:1st Division
Kermit Cintron: 1st Division
Paul Williams:2nd Division (1st:160)
CarlosQuintana:1st Division
Floyd Mayweather 4th Division

If you say Mayweather has grown into the Welther weight division even though that is his 4th Division


PLease Answer this Direct Question:

1.If Mayweather Has grown into a Natural WW, What Have the Other Fighters who have been in the WW division Grown into if that is their 1st or 2nd Division..?
or do you think that Mayweather is the only fighter who Grows in the Division?

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5117184&highlight=tune#post5117184

Here is the Logic:

Boxers have 17 weight classes to fit into. They should be compelled to fight within the one that most nearly reflects their actual trim and fit weight.

The primary objective of having 17 weight classes in this sport should be to determine the best fighters within specific intervals of weight. Not to pick on Margarito, but if he weighs a trim and fit 165 lbs. on fight night, then how on Earth can we call him the 147 lb. champion with a straight face?
Why have so many weight classes if the boxers being weighed are going to make a mockery of the system?

.

[PoetryInMotion]

Dude, thats the same exaxtct thing Ive been saying in Floyds favor at WW for years. Do you think Margarito, Cotto, Mosley, or any of those guys would hold Floyd's joke if Floyd was a natural WW who came into the ring at 162 pounds like them? He would destroy all of trhem but none of them fear him because he comes in at 148 and all of them will have 14-22 pounds on him in the ring. I dont hear any of you ever complaing about that. Everything you guys have been saying about JMM is the same thing that Ive been saying about Floyd fo years but no one cared then and they still dont now. How come you ccry about this but yet you think its so fair for Floyd to have to fight all the WW's who come in between162-170 pounds while he only comes in at 148. How is that fair? You never say anything and instead you call him a punk for not jumping to fight them, like he's a real WW. You guys still try to play him as a real WW even though he's fighting at the same weight on fight night that Pac has been doing since 130

So why not move down in weight if your Floyd and the WW are too big for him? Why instead stay at WW and make LW climb up to meet him?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Whats Floyds naural weight????????

[PoetryInMotion]

Dude, thats the same exaxtct thing Ive been saying in Floyds favor at WW for years. Do you think Margarito, Cotto, Mosley, or any of those guys would hold Floyd's joke if Floyd was a natural WW who came into the ring at 162 pounds like them? He would destroy all of trhem but none of them fear him because he comes in at 148 and all of them will have 14-22 pounds on him in the ring. I dont hear any of you ever complaing about that. Everything you guys have been saying about JMM is the same thing that Ive been saying about Floyd fo years but no one cared then and they still dont now. How come you ccry about this but yet you think its so fair for Floyd to have to fight all the WW's who come in between162-170 pounds while he only comes in at 148. How is that fair? You never say anything and instead you call him a punk for not jumping to fight them, like he's a real WW. You guys still try to play him as a real WW even though he's fighting at the same weight on fight night that Pac has been doing since 130

So you dont think Floyd should be fighting JMM? Or is it ok only when Floyd is the bigger man?

[VaBoriKua 2.0]

126.....super bantumweight

your wrong cause 27 of floyds 39 fights were at 130 super featherweight everything else is above 130