Mayweather vs. Cotto. In July. Who do you think would win?

[D-Omonist]

Cotto's suspect stamina
Cotto's suspect defense
Cotto's suspect chin

To

Floyd's excellent stamina
Floyd's excellent defense
Floyd's accuracy


Not being biased. Just what I see.

As you said SUSPECT. That's the key word there. As for suspect defense...nah I think he has good defense. Chin well we shall see.

[Rich Loc]

I can do that in another thread. This is about Mayweather.

Would you rate Baldomir as an A+ win?

If it’s about Mayweather why did you bring in Erdei????


Baldomir win is a B– win

[nujabes77]

mayweather beats cotton, believe that

[AztecWanker]

As you said SUSPECT. That's the key word there. As for suspect defense...nah I think he has good defense. Chin well we shall see.

I disagree. When a fighter as slow as Margarito tags you clean repeatedly, you have suspect (or crap) defense.

Judah wobbled his ass, as did Mosley. Basically, every elite fighter tags his ass clean.

[D-Omonist]

I disagree. When a fighter as slow as Margarito tags you clean repeatedly, you have suspect (or crap) defense.

Judah wobbled his ass, as did Mosley. Basically, every elite fighter tags his ass clean.

I somewhat agree with the above, but it's boxing and almost everyone can land a few good shots in a fight.

I also think that he can't have both a suspect chin and defense. He has a pretty good record (more than good), and he wouldn't have gotten where he is now if he had crappy defense AND a suspect chin.

[BattlingNelson]

If it’s about Mayweather why did you bring in Erdei????


Baldomir win is a B– win

I brought in Erdei as he's a linear champion as well as Baldo. Titles doesn't make champions. Fighters do.

And since you only rate the Baldomir fight as a B- win I suggest a little less hype on behalf of that win would be appropriate.

[Chuckguy]

I disagree. When a fighter as slow as Margarito tags you clean repeatedly, you have suspect (or crap) defense.

Judah wobbled his ass, as did Mosley. Basically, every elite fighter tags his ass clean.

Ill give you that bro but they both hit a lot harder than Floyd
I have Floyd on points like 116-112 maybe even 117-111
but it would be a tough fight

[goblin]

i dont understand it..How come all people do is say that pbf is avoiding cotto and marg yet whenever theres a poll with floyd vs these 2 floyd always seems to win..im sure its out there but i swear ive never seen floyd lose a poll vs today's opposition.

[Boxer1590]

hmm considering Cotto is fighting Clottey in June, I doubt Cotto would be fighting Mayweather in July.

[Pullcounter]

i dont understand it..How come all people do is say that pbf is avoiding cotto and marg yet whenever theres a poll with floyd vs these 2 floyd always seems to win..im sure its out there but i swear ive never seen floyd lose a poll vs today's opposition.

cause cotto is beatable