NSB: Would you rather have Floyd fight the BEST of any weightclass or Just WW?

[El Dominicano]

fighting JMM above 140 is not a GREAT win.. its a good win...

I want to see GREAT wins...


But I am ok with this fight as a stepping stone to fight pac...

I have no real quarrel with this fight happening... only when posters say if Floyd beats JMM above 140 its a GREAT win...

Then again JMM is more proven then Pacquaio over 130, in that he beat Casamayor and Baby Bull

[El Dominicano]

JMM then Pac then Cotto or Shane or whoever is the man at WW.

I'm with you on that but all I really care for is Mayweather vs Pacquaio. That would be good enough for me JAT!

[Owlzfan84]

Here's the thing on why most ppl are upset. If he wants to fight at Welterweight, he should fight WELTERWEIGHTS! if he wants to fight Pacman and JMM fights should be at 140, a weight thats his "more natural weightclass" according to his fans.

[HK45]

Please address this post..do not rant and get off topic..
I tryed to reason with you and agreed that if Floyd CALL OUT a smaller fighter then he should go down to that fighters weight class and fight him.


BUT YOU SHOULD HAVENT ADDRESS WHAT ABOUT FIGHTERS WHO CALL OUT FLOYD?

if a smaller fighter or bigger fighter calls out floyd then that smaller or bigger fighter should go to floyd weight class...dont you agree?

No, in Floyd's case is just an excuse to not fight a true welterweight then after he beats Marquez call himself the best WW out there.

[El Dominicano]

Here's the thing on why most ppl are upset. If he wants to fight at Welterweight, he should fight WELTERWEIGHTS! if he wants to fight Pacman and JMM fights should be at 140, a weight thats his "more natural weightclass" according to his fans.

Here is what people don't understand, why should Mayweather fight Pacquaio at 140 when they'll both weight the same FIGHT NIGHT

[HK45]

Here is what people don't understand, why should Mayweather fight Pacquaio at 140 when they'll both weight the same FIGHT NIGHT

So, if that's truth then what's the problem with fighting either Pac or JMM at 140.

[IMDAZED]

Using "fight night weight" as logic, Ricky Hatton should be at 154.

[Horus]

Floyd can fight JMM @ 147 if he wants to. Floyd has the power and the money to call the shots. Just dont call such a fight legacy enhancing because it clearly isn't.

So I guess you think Bernard Hopkins Win over De la Hoya wasnt a legacy enhancing and you had a problem with Hopkins Fighting a jr.middleweight De La hoya at the time instead of a top middleweight


So I guess you think Oscar De La Hoya fight with Mayweather wasnt a opportunity at a legacy enhancing win. and you had a problem with Oscar De La Hoya Fighting a small welterweight in Mayweather at the time instead of a top jr.middleweightmiddleweight

So I guess you think Marvin Hagler win over Thomas Hearns wasnt a legacy enhancing and you had a problem with Marvin Hagler Fighting a jr. Middleweight in Thomas Hearns at the time instead of a top middleweight

Also I guess you dont think Marvin Hagler win over duran wasnt a legacy enhancing win since he fought Duran at middleweight.

Answer me this:

Why is that Mosely& Cotto can call out Pacquaio and Hatton but Floyd can't?
(which he still havent did)

Do you think Mosley or Cotto will go down to 140 to fight them or expect them to come to 147?

Why cant Floyd fight people his own size and even smaller then him when he himself is a small dude fighting bigger dudes all the time is my point...


People get mad because I apply the standards on other fighters that they apply to Floyd...but my whole thing is dont be a hypocrite.

1. If you think it is Cool for Pacquaio to fight Hatton...Then you should think it's Cool For Pacquaio to fight Floyd...
   
2. If you think It's cool for Floyd to fight Paul Williams, then you should think it's cool for Floyd to fight somebody has tremendous physical advantages over...

You get my point.... DONT MAKE SPECIAL RULES for Floyd and not everybody else. thats been my problem from day 1.

DOUBLE STANDARDS

[El Dominicano]

So, if that's truth then what's the problem with fighting either Pac or JMM at 140.

Whats the problem with not facing Mayweather at 147? Regardles of which weight they chose to fight in, Mayweather will be 147(Fight Night)

I could ask the same question

[IMDAZED]

[FONT="Tahoma"]So I guess you think Bernard Hopkins Win over De la Hoya wasnt a legacy enhancing and you had a problem with Hopkins Fighting a jr.middleweight De La hoya at the time instead of a top middleweight

Yeah except Hopkins weighed 156 for DLH.