Oscar is champion in 5 weight classes NOT 6

[Rich Loc]

Why do people say champion in 6 weight classes. The strum fight was a robbery.

[Dynamite Kid]

Why do people say champion in 6 weight classes. The strum fight was a robbery.

So was Holy's win 1st win over John Ruiz. Well not a robbery, but he did not win thats for sure. Im a Holy fan to.

[2501]

Why do people say champion in 6 weight classes. The strum fight was a robbery.

So any fight that is perceived as a robbery by a majority shouldnt count as win?

[Butterball]

Really they should put the "world" in quotation marks as Hopkins was the real champion anyway, but I did count that as a legit win for Oscar. Sturm's output was really low in that fight.

[Rich Loc]

So any fight that is perceived as a robbery by a majority shouldnt count as win?

Difference between a close fight which any fighter could have gotten the nod. Or Highway Robbery eg JCC/Pernell Holyfield/Lewis

[Vasyl’s dad]

Castillo beat Floyd in the first fight.


The record book says "robbery" though.

[Burner]

Why do people say champion in 6 weight classes. The strum fight was a robbery.

Yeah I always think about that...Oscar was out of shape as ****.

[ulises_solis]

so floyd isnt undefeated he lost to castillo
etc
its written in stone oscar is the first 6 division champion

[Rich Loc]

Castillo beat Floyd in the first fight.


The record book says "robbery" though.

What record book??? Did Castillo lodge an official complaint like Strum did??

Ike Strum Pernell all beat Oscar

[Spiegelo]

Really they should put the "world" in quotation marks as Hopkins was the real champion anyway, but I did count that as a legit win for Oscar. Sturm's output was really low in that fight.

Shh, don't comment on the fight itself, Malcom never actually saw it anyway. It's simply been more than 10 minutes since his last whack thread, so he's making a new one. No sense using logic, don't even bother..