would Floyds record resemble Oscars if...

[Cortezsucks]

Hopkins kills him in 3rds.

Tito at 147 and Mosley at 147 beat him.

Floyd scrapped a SD against a past it Oscar.

[El Dominicano]

what problems do you see bhop givin floyd?

B-Hop is bigger, simple as that. B-Hop will beat him both inside and out...P4P, it'd be another story, I wouldn't be able to make a pick.

[Bushbaby]

Other than B-HOP being 6-1 and a defensive master in his own right and both being counter punchers and the fact that Floyd doesnt put together to much offense and that B-HOP seems to only have a problem with high output fighters,theres no reason!!Since we are at it,who has floyd fought,to compare to say,Mosley,Trinidad,B-Hop,Ike,Vargas or Pacman!!!Floyds skill have only been tested by an old DeLaHoya,whom he barely beat!!

[Pullcounter]

Meaning if he'd fought:

Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Manny Pacquiao

floyd possibly beats tito

floyd probably beats mosley

floyd loses to hopkins

floyd beats pac

[Fenom]

"I have him beating BHop'


BAN

Join Date: Apr 2009

[FLY TY]

Hopkins kills him in 3rds.

Tito at 147 and Mosley at 147 beat him.

Floyd scrapped a SD against a past it Oscar.

that split decision garage was nonsense.....

oscar won 3, maybe 4 rounds of that fight.......

even max kellerman said, giving oscar 5 rounds was stretching it, but for ANYONE to have oscar winning that fight was ridiculous....i concur.

its funny how ppl try to discredit floyd, in a fight in which all the cards were stacked against him, not the least of which was moving UP, fighting in a weight he had never fought at before, but in a fight he CLEARLY won......all b/c we had 1 rogue judge...

[MANGLER]

[QUOTE=Busy;5090051]

Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Manny Pacquiao


At 147 I'd pick him over Felix, but there's certainly a chance for Mr boat buyer to be KTFO. At 147 prime SSM beats him. At 160 Bhop winnin is a no brainer. At 147 he KO's Pac handily.

[Fenom]

B-Hop is bigger, simple as that. B-Hop will beat him both inside and out...P4P, it'd be another story, I wouldn't be able to make a pick.

ok

Other than B-HOP being 6-1 and a defensive master in his own right and both being counter punchers and the fact that Floyd doesnt put together to much offense and that B-HOP seems to only have a problem with high output fighters,theres no reason!!Since we are at it,who has floyd fought,to compare to say,Mosley,Trinidad,B-Hop,Ike,Vargas or Pacman!!!Floyds skill have only been tested by an old DeLaHoya,whom he barely beat!!

thats a good point... Chico was 5′ 10½″ and had reports of being taller but i def see what your saying... size can definitely play a big roll

then again you can look at examples like Paul Williams (6′ 1″) and Quintana (5′ 9½″), if they dont know how to use that size it doesnt make a difference

[Cortezsucks]

that split decision garage was nonsense.....

oscar won 3, maybe 4 rounds of that fight.......

even max kellerman said, giving oscar 5 rounds was stretching it, but for ANYONE to have oscar winning that fight was ridiculous....i concur.

its funny how ppl try to discredit floyd, in a fight in which all the cards were stacked against him, not the least of which was moving UP, fighting in a weight he had never fought at before, but in a fight he CLEARLY won......all b/c we had 1 rogue judge...

Common you think Floyd beats a prime 147 Oscar, Mosley, Tito?

[larry x]

floyd loses to hopknis,,,but could very well have beaten everyone else