would Floyds record resemble Oscars if...

**mike ruler** · 04-17-2009, 12:36 PM

Originally posted by Busy

he'd fought everyone Oscar did?

Oscar: 39 Wins 6 Losses 0 Draws

Floyd: 39 Wins 0 Losses 0 Draws

Meaning if he'd fought:

Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Manny Pacquiao

and did everything to the tee that Oscar did (i.e. moving up to middleweight to fight BHop) how would he fair?

I have him beating BHop & Felix by decision (moving up to middle for BHop wouldnt effect him that much)

And a 2000 154 Shane & Manny both being fireworks, both especially Pacquiao would force him to fight... i think he'd decision Shane, and with Pacquiao he'd land the cleaner blows to take a decision, maybe even stop him on cuts

that's redonculous!!!

**Fenom** · 04-17-2009, 12:38 PM

Originally posted by mike ruler

that's redonculous!!!

you think so? i figured i'd catch some slack on the bhop fight but honestly i think it'd be a real strategic, methodical fight

I know mays no workhorse but bernards not that active, he looks for counters which floyd wouldnt be giving.... plus he's so quick i dont see bernard being able to take advantage even if he was

**Fulcrum29** · 04-17-2009, 12:49 PM

depends when they fight, on one hand I figure well damn Hopkins would own floyd on the other hand jermain taylor owned bhop twice I think if he can, floyd can.

**AztecWanker** · 04-17-2009, 12:50 PM

Floyd loses to B-Hop and possibly prime Ike and prime Shane. That's about it.

**El Dominicano** · 04-17-2009, 12:55 PM

Mayweather beating B-Hop NOT HAPPENING. In a P4P match up, I couldn't make a pick but listen back to the subject. He'll beat Tito, Shane, Pac but I believe he'll lose to Ike and I'm damn sure he'll lose to B-Hop.

**Welter_Skelter** · 04-17-2009, 12:59 PM

Originally posted by Busy

he'd fought everyone Oscar did?

Oscar: 39 Wins 6 Losses 0 Draws

Floyd: 39 Wins 0 Losses 0 Draws

Meaning if he'd fought:

Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Manny Pacquiao

and did everything to the tee that Oscar did (i.e. moving up to middleweight to fight BHop) how would he fair?

I have him beating BHop & Felix by decision (moving up to middle for BHop wouldnt effect him that much)

And a 2000 154 Shane & Manny both being fireworks, both especially Pacquiao would force him to fight... i think he'd decision Shane, and with Pacquiao he'd land the cleaner blows to take a decision, maybe even stop him on cuts

He would likely have a loss to Mosley and maybe 1 more somewhere along the way.. Then again he could conceivably beat them all..

**FLY TY** · 04-17-2009, 01:03 PM

oscar is bigger than floyd, so is trinidad......not a fair question. floyd would've been at a HUGE disadvantage fighting hopkins at MW, don't be ridiculous.

floyd beats mosley, prime or no prime.

**Fenom** · 04-17-2009, 01:04 PM

Originally posted by El Dominicano

Mayweather beating B-Hop NOT HAPPENING. In a P4P match up, I couldn't make a pick but listen back to the subject. He'll beat Tito, Shane, Pac but I believe he'll lose to Ike and I'm damn sure he'll lose to B-Hop.

what problems do you see bhop givin floyd?

**Cortezsucks** · 04-17-2009, 01:05 PM

Originally posted by Busy

he'd fought everyone Oscar did?

Oscar: 39 Wins 6 Losses 0 Draws

Floyd: 39 Wins 0 Losses 0 Draws

Meaning if he'd fought:

Felix Trinidad
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Manny Pacquiao

and did everything to the tee that Oscar did (i.e. moving up to middleweight to fight BHop) how would he fair?

I have him beating BHop & Felix by decision (moving up to middle for BHop wouldnt effect him that much)

And a 2000 154 Shane & Manny both being fireworks, both especially Pacquiao would force him to fight... i think he'd decision Shane, and with Pacquiao he'd land the cleaner blows to take a decision, maybe even stop him on cuts

"I have him beating BHop'

BAN

would Floyds record resemble Oscars if...