Top 10 WelterWeights

[dans]

How does that even make sense? Williams most notable wins at 147 were Margarito and Quintana (rematch)
Mosley destroyed Margarito, lost a decision to Cotto
Cotto beat Quintana, Malignaggi, Mosley, Judah

Don't try reasoning with burner. Logic doesn't work with him.

[PR Boxer]

how do u put mosley over cotto when cotto beat mosley? and no dont bring margarito up when he cheated.

We all know Margarito cheated but officially we have to recognize that Mosley beat Margarito and officially it went into the books that Margarito won the Cotto fight, so officially Mosley has to be number one since he beat the guy who beat the guy who was #1 at the time, when Cotto takes legal action towards Margarito and if the loss is changed to a No Contest, then we can recognize Cotto officially as #1 in the Welterweight division.

[MaFu MoFo]

We all know Margarito cheated but officially we have to recognize that Mosley beat Margarito and officially it went into the books that Margarito won the Cotto fight, so officially Mosley has to be number one since he beat the guy who beat the guy who was #1 at the time, when Cotto takes legal action towards Margarito and if the loss is changed to a No Contest, then we can recognize Cotto officially as #1 in the Welterweight division.

Shi-t is not going to happen, sad but true...

[BOOMbip]

I don't understand why people put Mosley ahead of Cotto when Cotto already holds a victory over Mosley and Miguel's only loss is under su****ion of foul play...

Any way list goes as such

1.Miguel Cotto
2. Shane Mosley
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Andre Berto

And these are the only 4 ww that matter at the present time...Plasterman is suspended and hopefully never fights again and I hope he gets ****d by a wolf with aids.

PWill is not going to be down at the WW division again....If he does ill sick EL Indio on him....and maybe he'll basicly win every exchange in every round for 12 rounds again ...or get knocked out in 1 round...which 1 is the fluke? who knows till the rubber match.

1 would think it would be much harder to give some one a sustained beating over 12...3 minute rounds out of sheer luck ...but logic doesnt seem to prevail on NSB.

Floyd,Pac,Hatton ....all other fringe/small guys...that don't want to fight at WW or only will to have an advantage on a smaller guy don't matter to me and are not real WW to me...therefore they don't exist..

So...Poof
Vamoose son of a *****.

[MaFu MoFo]

I don't understand why people put Mosley ahead of Cotto when Cotto already holds a victory over Mosley and Miguel's only loss is under su****ion of foul play...

Any way list goes as such

1.Miguel Cotto
2. Shane Mosley
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Andre Berto

And these are the only 4 ww that matter at the present time...Plasterman is suspended and hopefully never fights again and I hope he gets ****d by a wolf with aids.

PWill is not going to be down at the WW division again....If he does ill sick EL Indio on him....and maybe he'll basicly win every exchange in every round for 12 rounds again ...or get knocked out in 1 round...which 1 is the fluke? who knows till the rubber match.

1 would think it would be much harder to give some one a sustained beating over 12...3 minute rounds out of sheer luck ...but logic doesnt seem to prevail on NSB.

Floyd,Pac,Hatton ....all other fringe/small guys...that don't want to fight at WW or only will to have an advantage on a smaller guy don't matter to me and are not real WW to me...therefore they don't exist..

So...Poof
Vamoose son of a *****.

I could agree with your post. Totally understand your point of view and respect it.

[baracuda]

1- SHANE MOSLEY
2- MIGUEL COTTO
3- PAUL WILLIAMS
4- JOSHUA CLOTTEY
5- ANTONIO MARGARITO
6- KERMIT CINTRON
7- ANDRE BERTO
8- CARLOS QUINTANA
9- LUIS COLLAZO
10- Vyacheslav Senchenko (had to copy, paste)


What's yours??? Feel free to comment on my list too.

i like your top 5 but i'd put berto and quintana ahead of cintron!

[MaFu MoFo]

i like your top 5 but i'd put berto and quintana ahead of cintron!

I would too, definitely Quintana, but I still got a softie place for Kermit. So many great KOs in his past.

[boxasmash]

1. cotto
2. mosley
3. margarito
4. clottey
5. quintana
6. berto
7. collazo
8. cintron
9. judah
10. brook

[monkeyboy]

The only loss on Cotto's record is a now very su****ious loss to Margherito. He beat Mosley so I still have him no.1. but with a need to justify it. A Clottey victory will do so.
Margherito is not a fighter and so is not on any list at all.

[MaFu MoFo]

1. cotto
2. mosley
3. margarito
4. clottey
5. quintana
6. berto
7. collazo
8. cintron
9. judah
10. brook

Good list, but I believe Judah should no longer be considered a top 10 WW.