Is Winky/Williams even Vegas worthy?

[MoneyMayFan]

prime for prime winky still whoops on titos ass. Oscar bitched out and lied on tv last night talking about he was willing to fight the top guys but he clearly ducked winky
he is really the first one to whoop on vargas. and he shoulda gave taylor his first L but instead judges bitched out

[deevel79]

That's intriguing. I'm really trying to think if he does... I'm not sure, that's a good one. I'm going to look for that thread.

Winky is a good defensive technician. I wouldnt classify him as ATG material though. He'll most likely make the HOF.

[MoneyMayFan]

I thought the way he acted after the Taylor fight was a little immature.

I think his style is a little lackluster, although effective.

yea i agree he should have went about it a lil different but he won that damn fight. I think the judges used that draw as a cop out. Taylor was the future and they didnt want that ''0'' to become a 1.

[Del Coqui]

prime for prime winky still whoops on titos ass. Oscar bitched out and lied on tv last night talking about he was willing to fight the top guys but he clearly ducked winky
he is really the first one to whoop on vargas. and he shoulda gave taylor his first L but instead judges bitched out

I disagree.

[deliveryman]

I actually kind of don't think so...

I mean, really, Mosley was probably out of his class at 154, and Trinidad clearly didn't have a lot left.

The thing was, he got a lot of credit for those wins because that was the first time that people saw either of those factors in either guy...

The Trinidad win is clearly less impressive than the Mosley wins though... the Mosley wins are still pretty good.

I think yahoo had something to do with it, so try that as a search criteria if you are having trouble.

Yeah, I am leaning towards just outside the top 10. I'd say Top 15.

I think he had the talent, he just didn't get the fights.

[MoneyMayFan]

winky was all wrong for tito. Last defensive genius he faced (b-hop) he got it handed to him. dont get me wrong tito was a great fighter but winky would have busted his ass prime for prime.

[Del Coqui]

winky was all wrong for tito. Last defensive genius he faced (b-hop) he got it handed to him. dont get me wrong tito was a great fighter but winky would have busted his ass prime for prime.

prime for prime Tito was a different fighter than the one Nard and Winky faced.

[Fox McCloud]

prime for prime Tito was a different fighter than the one Nard and Winky faced.

This is true... I'm not willing to make a determination on his if beats Tito in his prime (because they were at 2 different weights), but... a middleweight Trinidad was not a prime one. Hopkins got a much better version of Trinidad than Wright did, and that's for damn sure.

[Haterfree]

The OP of this thread was a Margarito. Now that his man has been exposed he wants to hate on 2 top fighters like Williams & Winky.

[MoneyMayFan]

People forget tito was the favorite in the winky fight. Its only less impressive when winky made it look easy