When did Joe Calzaghe become an ATG??

[Dorian]

probably after 21 title defenses, winning all of the belts at 168, then moving up and beating top 5 p4p hopkins. I wouldn't put him in the top 50, but he definitely cracks the top 100 atg list.

Wonder what your two active threads have in common there flawless?

end of thread!

[Abstraction]

Waste of Talent.

It;s only the Bias Fans that come out with ridiculous attempts to rate him.

Rofl, the fact that someone says he is good because he beat someguy called Pudwill? just shows how delusional his "Fans" are.

[Slater P Persin]

he's only ATG in the UK

Wow! That's like being the tallest midget in the circus.

[Slater P Persin]

Probably after 21 title defenses, winning all of the belts at 168, then moving up and beating top 5 p4p Hopkins. I wouldn't put him in the top 50, but he definitely cracks the top 100 ATG list.

Wonder what your two active threads have in common there Flawless?

21 WBO title defenses. Not quite the same as 21 real title defenses. Sorry!

[boxasmash]

21 title defences undefeated, undisputed champion, 2 weight champion over a stretch of 11 years.

pretty much makes you an atg, add the names roy jones, bernard hopkins, mikkel kessler, chris eubank and jeff lacy and thats just the icing on the cake.

you can put an asterix next to a few of those names, but he still got them on his resume.

[Rich Loc]

No one really answered my question
When did he thought Calzaghe become an ATG?? After his Kessler win or after his Hopkins win

[Zn1]

Dariusz Michalczewski defended his WBO light heavyweight title 23 times and was a two weight division champion

Does that make him an ATG??

Calzaghe's win over Hopkins is questionable. It was not even a good performance

gotta agree, after a few rounds hopkins went back to his usual hit once, hold a few hundred times. rinse..... awful performance

and yeah. if only cortez had let hatton hold 5% as much as he let hopkins hold

sure u can guess which fights im referencing

[boxasmash]

No one really answered my question
When did he thought Calzaghe become an ATG?? After his Kessler win or after his Hopkins win

hmmmm, after the hopkins fight i'd say.

the fight was messy but he became a 2 weight champion and had a legend on his resume.