Which is the more impressive win?

[QUISQUEYA]

Hatton's win over Tzyu...the guy was ranked number 2 p4p in the world when hatton beat him, and was a 7-1 underdog......OR

Pacquiao's win over Oscar De la Hoya at welterweight and was 2-1 underdog....

which is the more impressive victory in the ole' resume?

Hatton's win.

Tszyu was just as "young" as DLH. Tszyu was fighting a his best weight. Tszyu was p4p ranked. Tszyu actually fought back, unlike DLH.

They were both past their best days. But nobody should be impressed by seeing an anorexic ****** get beat up. That happens every night on Hollywood Boulevard.

[S.G.]

i'll say hatton's.

both wins are overrated though imo

[QUISQUEYA]

106 LBS!!!!

oscar fought as high as middleweight!!!

106 LBS!!!!

PullCounter,

Please. stop yourself.

Manny was at 106 pounds when he was sixteen years old. He turned pro. When PBF was sixteen, he won the National Golden Gloves. Guess at what weight?

I'll leave that one to you.

[Miburo]

I'd rate them about evenly. Similar circumstances in both.

[El Dominicano]

Too many ****** people on this site. To think it is close, the hell would I give Pac credit for beating that version of DLH. Anyone would have beaten DLH that night, even feather fisted Paulie

[El Dominicano]

PullCounter,

Please. stop yourself.

Manny was at 106 pounds when he was sixteen years old. He turned pro. When PBF was sixteen, he won the National Golden Gloves. Guess at what weight?

I'll leave that one to you.

Everyone's saying that! My older brother who just came back from Iraq was still growing at 23. Never understood people saying Pac is a FW beating up on SFW's and LW's