Who do you consider the best at 147?

[madhatter]

Forgetting about the whole plaster scandal Shane is #1 because of how enfatically he beat Margarito, but cotto is a close second and i agree their has to be a rematch between the two.

[savorduhflavor]

He avenged his loss In emphatic fashion. Proving his 1st loss was an off night.

That is seriously unbelievable.

Ok, well Quintana won the first fight over 12 rounds, which proves the second fight was just an off night.

See, I can do that too.

Why can't you Paul Williams fans take the loss for what it was worth. He lost, and he avenged his victory. That's great that he did that no doubt. But it doesn't prove **** about the first fight being a fluke, be real.

[Milkyway12]

So the first fight magically disapear?

PW 12 RND loss to Quintana + 1 rnd from second fight = 13 RNDS
Cotto beat Quintana in just 5 RNDS

AT welterweight Cotto > PW

Quitto is no where near Williams. Williams beat Quittos daddy.

[Rompeboca]

He avenged his loss In emphatic fashion. Proving his 1st loss was an off night.

When Cotto loss against Margacheato you call him a Bum, but PW lossing to Quintana was an off night? BS!!!

[yeykax]

Right now Cotto,Mosley.Plp debate Pwill is one of the best because he beat Margo and it a way it makes sense if you no that Pwill beat the man,that beat the man (plaster or not),that lost to the man .that got beat by the man...Follow??Well it all comes down to Cotto is The man in W.W!!

[MANGLER]

SSM is the man to beat as of now.

[Rompeboca]

Quitto is no where near Williams. Williams beat Quittos daddy.

so....Cotto beat PW's Daddy(Quintana)...

lol what a weak argument, Who old are you? 3?
Cotto's record > than PW record

[cubanprospect]

Rompeboca, cotto always picks very carefully his opponents. He got the nerve to call himself the WBO champ, yes what a champ waiting for the PW's title to get vacated and fight a nobody.

By the way PW loosing to Quintana is similar to Lennox loosing to Rahman, and then beating the crap out of Rahman in the second fight; nobody is questioning Lennox's ability to beat Rahman, the same way noobody outside Puerto Rico is questioning PW's ability to beat the hell out of Quintana.

Cotto's is very limited, he cannot go down to 140 but is more than willing to fight the Midgets Hatton and Pacquiao at 147 - wtf???
At 147 he is too small to face a prime REAL CHAMPION figther naturally bigger than he is, and at 154 forget it.

COTTO WAY OVERRATED!!!!

[cubanprospect]

forgot to mention, PW is of course the best BUT NOBODY IS WILLING TO EVEN MENTION HIS NAME AT 147.

and we all know that he is willing to go down to 147 and fight!

[Pullcounter]

mosley is the man to beat at 147