Who is the better fighter Cotto or Margarito?

[KostyaTszyu44]

skillwise and talent wise cotto is much better, however so far head to head margarito has the win over miguel, but we cant be sure whether he cheated or not

[Mr. Fantastic]

Enlight us, how Margarito is the better fighter!!!!

He beat Cotto, not just beat him, he made him quit.
He has more successful title defenses than him.
He has been a champion longer than Cotto.
He has actually beaten a champion to get a belt.

Like I said, when Cotto goes in with a Williams, Clottey and beats them decisively then I would think otherwise, but at this point. Nope.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Do you realize, Naz found them by accident?

Sure he did lol

[ACHlLLES]

Do you realize, Naz found them by accident?

Margarito is better because of his plaster, and the only reason his chin was granite in the other fights is because he tired out his opponents by beating them with his plasterered hands. Not going to be alot of pop from your opponent when you're basically beating them with bricks.

[BMWM3P]

He beat Cotto, not just beat him, he made him quit.
He has more successful title defenses than him.
He has been a champion longer than Cotto.
He has actually beaten a champion to get a belt.

Like I said, when Cotto goes in with a Williams, Clottey and beats them decisively then I would think otherwise, but at this point. Nope.

This dumb ***** doesn't know when to call it quits.

[Mr. Fantastic]

This dumb ***** doesn't know when to call it quits.

Ok Ok, Cotto is a fucking God, he can beat everyone. He has skills better than Whitaker, he hits harder than Earnie Shavers, he has the best chin ever. He's a perfect boxer. You happy you ***?? Go fuck yourself.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He beat Cotto, not just beat him, he made him quit.
He has more successful title defenses than him.
He has been a champion longer than Cotto.
He has actually beaten a champion to get a belt.

Like I said, when Cotto goes in with a Williams, Clottey and beats them decisively then I would think otherwise, but at this point. Nope.

Magarito only have 8 succesful title defenses(9 Overall), Cotto have 10 succesfull title defenses(11 Overall).
Cotto has been a 2 division Chmapion, while Margarito fail to do so!!!!!!

Cotto as been a 3 time champion just as Magarito, the only champ he has beated for a belt is Cintron for the IBF title in 08. SO whats better, beating Cintron for the IBF,belt or beat Quitana, for the vacant WBA belt. The same Quintana that Schooled Williams, who beated Magarito.

And when Margarito beats a Shane Mosley, then maybe then Ill consider him a decent fighter!!!!!!!!

[Mr. Fantastic]

Magarito only have 8 succesful title defenses(9 Overall), Cotto have 10 succesfull title defenses(11 Overall).
Cotto has been a 2 division Chmapion, while Margarito fail to do so!!!!!!

Cotto as been a 3 time champion just as Magarito, the only champ he has beated for a belt is Cintron for the IBF title in 08. SO whats better, beating Cintron for the IBF,belt or beat Quitana, for the vacant WBA belt. The same Quintana that Schooled Williams, who beated Magarito.

And when Margarito beats a Shane Mosley, then maybe then Ill consider him a decent fighter!!!!!!!!

Fail to do so due to some home cooking. Its all good though.

You forget he beat Cotto for his belt too. Whether you like it or not.

[..WaRSpencE..]

He beat Cotto, not just beat him, he made him quit.
He has more successful title defenses than him.
He has been a champion longer than Cotto.
He has actually beaten a champion to get a belt.

Like I said, when Cotto goes in with a Williams, Clottey and beats them decisively then I would think otherwise, but at this point. Nope.

Cotto became Pro 7 years after Margarito
Cotto outboxed Mosley..who is better than any Margarito's "Title defenses"
Margarito now has a HUGE cloud called "Plaster of Paris" over his victories


Cotto has nothing to prove..his only loss is definitely now questionable..and you're still too stubborn to admit it..there is no proof..but there isn't proof of god or Jesus Christ but damn it I BELIEVE!..and I'm sure you do too..

I know how being in denial can feel sometimes..not personally..but from what I see in the similarities with people who can't admit to ****...it sucks...but to each their own..look at any Cotto fight and compare it to ANY Margarito fight and the answer is obvious..Cotto is a FAR Superior fighter over Margarito..his accomplishments may not be all up there..but I bet in the 7 year difference Cotto has done far better and will easily surpass any Margarito accomplishment..with out the plaster!

[MANGLER]

Marg is tougher, but in terms of skill Cotto mos def is better.