Who is higher on ATG list: Mayweather, Hopkins or Pacquiao?

[iecen]

How can you rate a guy that fights smaller guys an all time great, what is Hopkins best win? Everyone talks about what ATG Floyd has beaten. How many ATG have Hopkins beaten? Fighting WW when your a MW doesnt make you great in my book.

[-EX-]

Well Manny hasn't beat anyone who's ranked very high on the all time list...Barrera and Morales are on there but not top 50.

[DrewWoodside]

Well Manny hasn't beat anyone who's ranked very high on the all time list...Barrera and Morales are on there but not top 50.

What of PBF's wins beat those two exactly?

[iecen]

How can you rate a guy that fights smaller guys an all time great, what is Hopkins best win? Everyone talks about what ATG Floyd has beaten. How many ATG have Hopkins beaten? Fighting WW when your a MW doesnt make you great in my book.

Please someone answer my question and get the knowledge.

How can you rate a guy that fights smaller guys an all time great, what is Hopkins best win? Everyone talks about what ATG Floyd has beaten. How many ATG have Hopkins beaten? Fighting WW when your a MW doesnt make you great in my book.

[mellow_mood]

nard, hands down.

[mellow_mood]

pull wtf?? u voted for pac?? how come!!

[Roger Mellie]

Pacquiao,mayweather and then hopkins.

[The Great Shark]

Bernard Hopkins no doubt, followed by Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather Jr.

[Roger Mellie]

With the exception of tarver,who is grossly overrated.All the other guys on bhops are smaller guys.

[DrewWoodside]

With the exception of tarver,who is grossly overrated.All the other guys on bhops are smaller guys.

Tarver is a solid fighter, and Hop also beat Glen Johnson and Kelly Pavlik both of whom spent the majority of their careers no lower than MW.