Who's higher on your ATG list - MAYWEATHER or CALZAGHE??

[Chunk..]

I think both guys are ATG, but Mayweather's a 5 weight World Champion and is also undefeated. He's also technically/skilled better then Cazaghe IMO.

[The Gambler1981]

jmm has entertained the fans more the last year or so than floyd has his whole career.

Being entertaining has nothing to do with who is a great fighter.

[Spacey1991]

Mayweather easily, Mayweather just at both 130-135 alone makes him higher.

[El Dominicano]

What about calzaghe beating Kessler? Kessler was an all time great in his prime.

Mayweather beating Zab or Baldy is a better win then unproven Kessler. Sad but true

[Bhopreign]

when he fights cotto pacman or mosley, then you can call him underrated.

Floyd started at 130, when Cotto goes up 3 classes and fights the best then ok.

[Technical_Skill]

Surprise Surprise, Tunney goes for Calzaghe

[Bhopreign]

Being entertaining has nothing to do with who is a great fighter.

Absolutley nothing.

[ironjab]

floyd all the way, much better opponents and he fought in the states much sooner than joe did.........lmao!

[El Dominicano]

BG Knocc Out and Hard Chaw, Tunney's alts?

Tunney and his 2 alts voted, how cute

[BG_Knocc_Out]

I'd say Calzaghe, everyone likes to say Calzaghe ducked everyone and waited for Hopkins and Jones to get old, but in reality, Jones is only 2-3 years older than Calzaghe, which really isn't much. I mean you take a look at Calzaghe's resume, in his first 25 fights, 23 of them were KO's. And then after those first 25, all the fighters he's faught all have dominant green bars for their last 6 fights. That's pretty impressive to me. Two reasons I believe people hate him so much is, 1: He's from Wales and most of his great fights took place there during his best years. 2: He has such a sloppy looking style, yet he does it so good and effective that people believe he has no talent or boxing skill that they think he's a disgrace. What makes me like Calzaghe is that, quoting what Nigel Benn said, is that he struggled with lesser opponents, and when he got bigger and bigger fights, he stepped his game up each and every time. He might have not been born with the natural ability to own his opponents, so he worked hard to better himself each fight which makes me have so much respect for him. He shows that anyone can work their way to the top, even with starting from nothing.