Who's higher on your ATG list - MAYWEATHER or CALZAGHE??

[BattlingNelson]

Of these 2 modern greats who deserves to be higher on your ATG list?

Remember: AllTimeGreatness is about what you HAVE accomplished and not what you COULD have accomplished.

Plese vote.

[Left Hook Tua]

mayweather.

both are extremely overrated imo but floyd's 130-135 career alone surpasses joe's crap of a resume.

[mellow_mood]

well man...

joe is great... but ... i think u can have a UD here... pbf

[Bhopreign]

Of these 2 modern greats who deserves to be higher on your ATG list?

Remember: AllTimeGreatness is about what you HAVE accomplished and not what you COULD have accomplished.

Plese vote.

For me its Floyd, the REAL pluses for Calzaghe is that he had all of those defenses, unified and went up to 175 and got the lineal title, still Floyd went through 5 divisions winning six belts, was lineal champ 3 times and had 13 title defenses of his own.

[Technical_Skill]

Oh Please.

Resume= Mayweather, actually got in the ring with prime hall of famers or guys who will be hall of fame.

Skills= Do we even need to go here?..........Nope.

[ßringer]

Mayweather at Lightweight was a thing of beauty. HIs accomplishments there alone rank him above Calzaghe IMO.

Joe is a great fighter, and an ATG. But there are a lot of question marks with his career.

And I'm not saying Floyd has no question marks : He obviously does. But his record of opposition is pretty damn good with Hernandez, Castillo X2, Corrales, Hatton, and the ******.

[Bhopreign]

mayweather.

both are extremely overrated imo but floyd's 130-135 career alone surpasses joe's crap of a resume.

Floyd is underated.

[street bully]

Three words Floyd Mayweather Junior.

[Da Hammer]

Easily Mayweather. Calzaghe's resume actually makes Floyd look like a god!

[Left Hook Tua]

Floyd is underated.

he's overrated.