My grades on Mayweather opponents

[IwatchBoxing]

That's why many feel that he is over-rated, and his pfp status was a reflection of his undefeated record, rather than his level of opposition.

B-C fighters, maybe it was based on skill. And how meny weight divsions he moved up.

I'd call Ray Robinson an A

Corrales , Castillo a C

Ricky Hatton a B....hmmm?

[johncs08]

The same can be said for Cotto and Tony.

They were NEVER A class fighters.

A level fighters don't get hit with the same ****** punches over and over again.

lmfao.....................e=good..i think you mean d+

no im serious. margarito is E+ fighter. but without his plaster F+? idk?

[Boxer1590]

He made the Dean's list.

Mayweather is/was a great fighter.

Guys like Jesus Chavez and Carlos Hernandez were top dogs in that weight class when Floyd beat them. Floyd was a beast at 130-135.

[IwatchBoxing]

Now Margo, Ponce de Leon, Erick Morales, Antonio Barrera, Golden boy, and JMM were all un-primed lol

you left out Mijares, Arce, Escobedo and the ghost

man !! Mexican boxing never seen such days....

[deevel79]

He made the Dean's list.

Mayweather is/was a great fighter.

Guys like Jesus Chavez and Carlos Hernandez were top dogs in that weight class when Floyd beat them. Floyd was a beast at 130-135.

Funny thing is, Floyd best wins/biggest accomplishments took place @ 130 & 135, yet he didnt recieve his pfp#1 status till later in his career when he took on lesser competition.

[larryx]

Funny thing is, Floyd best wins/biggest accomplishments took place @ 130 & 135, yet he didnt recieve his pfp#1 status till later in his career when he took on lesser competition.

cause 140-154 was icing on the cake..he spend most of his career at 130-135

[IwatchBoxing]

Ricky Hatton KO'd an unprimed Luis Castillo in 4

[Parody]

Jose Luis Castillo - A
Diego Corrales - A
Ricky Hatton - A
Genaro Hernandez - B+
Jesus Chavez - B+
Oscar De La Hoya - B
Zab Judah - B
Carlos Hernandez B-
Carlos Baldomir - B-
Angel Manfredy - C+
Phillip N'Dou - C+
Demarcus Corley - C+
Arturo Gatti - C
Sharmba Mitchell - C-

[IwatchBoxing]

Jose Luis Castillo - C-
Diego Corrales - C-
Ricky Hatton - B-
Genaro Hernandez - ?
Jesus Chavez - C-
Oscar De La Hoya - B-
Zab Judah - C-
Carlos Hernandez ?
Carlos Baldomir - C-
Angel Manfredy - C-
Phillip N'Dou - ?
Demarcus Corley - C-
Arturo Gatti - C-
Sharmba Mitchell - C-

one last post, fixed that for you....

[deevel79]

cause 140-154 was icing on the cake..he spend most of his career at 130-135

I dont know about it being icing on the cake, but ok. My question is, if he spent most of his career at 130-135, and his biggest wins/accomplishents took place at those weight classes, how come he wasnt recognized as pfp#1 back then. Why did they wait for him to fight guys like Gatti and Baldomir to award him that title? It just doesnt make any sense.