Will Americans accept Hatton as an all time great if he beats Pacquiao?

[andrewcuff]

An ATG?

Amazing the things you read here.

That was my reaction.

[Savino]

The is no chance.

[P4P GOAT]

Beating a a blown up Flyweight and wrestling your way to victory over Kostya Tszyu does not do it for me.

[celt80]

If hatton beats the pac man, JMM and the rest of the light welterweight ABC Champs then I would consider him an ATG. It would make an impressive CV

[Chups]

NO! Only a surefire hall of famer. That is all.

[andrewcuff]

Both Tszyu & Castillo were not at their respective peaks when Hatton fought them so I'd hardly use them as a basis for an ATG claim.

[street bully]

Was Buster Douglas recognized as an ATG after he beat the most feared and revered fighter on the planet?

[baracuda]

He'll have fought 4 ring legends in Tszyu, Castillo, Mayweather and Pacquiao and beaten 3 out of four of them (as well as 40 others)

Will fat yanks accept him as one of the atgs if he wins?

first of all,he did not beat tzu nor luis collazo.secondly,juan lazcano would a have knocked him out if not because of the bad refereeing.finally'he can not even go past an old oscar like he wants us to believe,not even zab judah who's not in the top 20.imo,america overrates him right now,how much more if he beats pacman.he'll be the best fighter of all time he he he,yeah right...

[Left2body]

This guy is crazy. I remember his PBF vs Hatton scored card. He had Hatton up 6 rounds to 3 rounds.

[Reggie Miller]

an ATG in england.