The only way to legitimize PBF/JMM...

[Roger Mellie]

Unless the smaller guys can come up and make a statement at welterweight first,then they shouldnt even bother talking about it.If Floyd comes back he should be making fights against the top welters,Cotto,Moseley,Williams etc.I am really not a fan of this catchweight nonsense.16 weight divisions is enough,surely people should either make fights at these weights or come in light if neccesary.Whoever started this moving of the goalposts so to speak has a lot to answer for.

[miamijohn]

I think a lot of you are forgetting that Floyd has and always will be a smaller welterweight. Physically he really isn't that much bigger than a Zab Judah or Ricky Hatton who are both natural 140 pounders.

they seemed to forgot that Mayweather like JMM and others moved up as well and he dipped out quick soon after. They seem to make him out to be a giant.

[MELLY-MEL...]

the only way to legitimize it is at 40 or less.

[Bushbaby]

I think a lot of you are forgetting that Floyd has and always will be a smaller welterweight. Physically he really isn't that much bigger than a Zab Judah or Ricky Hatton who are both natural 140 pounders.

U know what,Cotto is a small welterweight too,but he still fought Margarito and he is now going to fight Clottey,small welterweight or not,how can u rule a division without fighting the best in that division,sounds like an excuse as to why Floyd shouldnt fight true welterweight elites to me!!!!

[El Chicano]

The only way to legitimize PBF/JMM as a real fight instead of a circus act, is for jmm to take a tune up at 147 (jmm can come under 147 if he wants) against a serious contender... say someone like collazo and beat him.

other than this pbf/jmm is a joke.

Or make Mayweather's ass come back down to 140. He's said in the past that he can do it.