Originally posted by Infern0
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Hatton Sr. Says Ricky Craves the Pound-for-Pound Title
Collapse
-
If you beat the best,then you earn the right to call yourself the best.Most people on here have Pacman as No.1,but if Ricky beats him those same people are going to say it doesnt count because its Hatton? GTFOH!!!!! nobheads!
Comment
-
Originally posted by mr.crust View PostIf you beat the best,then you earn the right to call yourself the best.Most people on here have Pacman as No.1,but if Ricky beats him those same people are going to say it doesnt count because its Hatton? GTFOH!!!!! nobheads!
either that, or he will be fitting carpets again by may 9th???
Comment
-
why do Hatton and his dad think if he beats pacman then he will automatically be P4P#1. if hatton beats pacman then JMM would move to #1 not Hatton. Hatton would move up to around 4
Comment
-
Hatton beats the so-called P4P champion then he takes the P4P#1 (it's a subjective and usually biasedly ranked label) spot or close to it since Hatton has beaten many champions already, including P4P ranked ones!
Comment
-
That's not how it works, if Pacquiao fought and lost at SuperWelterweight the person who beat him would not become PFP1#
Pacquiao would drop in rank, Hatton would go up, and the no.2 would probably go one. It's a ranking, you don't take the position of the person you beat.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Infern0 View PostHatton can never be p4p number one, never.
If he beat Pacquiao and Marquez decisively (which I consider unlikely, but still), and if Mayweather stayed retired, I think it's quite plausible that The Ring would rate him at #1.
Hopkins is unlikely to be rated #1 at this stage in his career unless he gets another huge and unexpected win, like maybe KO-ing Dawson (and he doesn't want to fight Dawson).
I doubt there's anything Vasquez or Mosley could do in the next year to make them #1 either.
When you consider who the current top 5 are, I don't see how anyone could say that beating both Pacquiao and Marquez decisively wouldn't be likely to be enough to give someone who is currently ranked #8 The Ring's P4P #1 ranking.
If he beat them narrowly and controversially it would be a different matter of course.
The Ring's current top 10:
1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Juan Manuel Marquez
3) Bernard Hopkins
4) Israel Vazquez
5) Shane Mosley
6) Rafael Marquez
7) Ivan Calderon
8) Ricky Hatton
9) Celestino Caballero
10) Vic DarchinyanLast edited by Dave Rado; 03-04-2009, 09:22 AM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Dave Rado View Post
When you consider who the current top 5 are, I don't see how anyone could say that beating both Pacquiao and Marquez decisively wouldn't be likely to be enough to give someone who is currently ranked #8 The Ring's P4P #1 ranking.
If he beat them narrowly and controversially it would be a different matter of course.
Hatton should have to win impressively to pass Pacquiao on the list.
I guess a similar situation would be if Chad Dawson fights Paul Williams at 175 and wins and then says he should be p4p #1 as a result.
Comment
Comment