Floyd Mayweather is good NOT great

[Rich Loc]

Mayweather is an ATG Top 25 without doubt. The people who deny this simply have an agenda or just pure haters, which it both sad

[Left Hook Tua]

Mayweather is an ATG Top 25 without doubt. The people who deny this simply have an agenda or just pure haters, which it both sad

muhammad ali
sugar ray robinson
henry armstrong
joe louis
roberto duran
jimmy wilde
archie moore
julio cesar chavez
marvin hagler
roy jones jr.
bernard hopkins
carlos monzon
george foreman
gene tunney
pernell whitaker
alexis arguello
salvador sanchez
ruben olivares
evander holyfield
thomas hearns
willie pep
bob fitzsimmons
wilfredo gomez
azumah nelson
carlos ortiz

there's 25. who you gonna bump off to make room for floyd mayweather?

**** there's dozens of guys that are greater than the guys i named , especially the old school ones.

[andrewcuff]

muhammad ali
sugar ray robinson
henry armstrong
joe louis
roberto duran
jimmy wilde
archie moore
julio cesar chavez
marvin hagler
roy jones jr.
bernard hopkins
carlos monzon
george foreman
gene tunney
pernell whitaker
alexis arguello
salvador sanchez
ruben olivares
evander holyfield
thomas hearns
willie pep
bob fitzsimmons
wilfredo gomez
azumah nelson
carlos ortiz

there's 25. who you gonna bump off to make room for floyd mayweather?

**** there's dozens of guys that are greater than the guys i named , especially the old school ones.

You need to bump off George Foreman and replace him with Ray Leonard lol

I see your point though. I have Floyd somewhere between 50-75 on my ATG list

[Left Hook Tua]

You need to bump off George Foreman and replace him with Ray Leonard lol

I see your point though. I have Floyd somewhere between 50-75 on my ATG list

i thought i put leonard...... oh **** i didn't.

i was just going off my head. it's not my top 25 list.

i was just thinking of guys that are not even debatable that can be bumped off in favor of floyd.

some of the old timers had more title wins than floyd had fights!

[andrewcuff]

i thought i put leonard...... oh **** i didn't.

i was just going off my head. it's not my top 25 list.

i was just thinking of guys that are not even debatable that can be bumped off in favor of floyd.

some of the old timers had more title wins than floyd had fights!

Yeah I know. I think people who say Floyd is top 25 (or even Top 40) just haven't seen enough other boxers to make an accurate list.

For example, there was a thread about Mayweather defence last week and one of his stans claimed he'd easily UD Benitez at 147. People like that should be tied down and forced to watch better fighters.

[Left Hook Tua]

Yeah I know. I think people who say Floyd is top 25 (or even Top 40) just haven't seen enough other boxers to make an accurate list.

For example, there was a thread about Mayweather defence last week and one of his stans claimed he'd easily UD Benitez at 147. People like that should be tied down and forced to watch better fighters.

every fighter has those kind of fans.

floyd's are the worse though.

i think one floyd stan posted one time that floyd would school duran because duran was a limited brawler and floyd would eat him up!

[andrewcuff]

every fighter has those kind of fans.

floyd's are the worse though.

i think one floyd stan posted one time that floyd would school duran because duran was a limited brawler and floyd would eat him up!

Yeah I've heard Floyd fanboys proclaiming his superiority over Duran as well. Firstly because he lost all his big fights and secondly because Floyd would never lose to the guys who beat Duran.

It make you wonder do they know of any other boxers besides Ali and Tyson before the 90s

[zojo]

lets be honest floyds skills are somewhat overrated too. if you think about it, fighting the opposition floyd does would make anyone look unbeatable.

[Left Hook Tua]

Yeah I've heard Floyd fanboys proclaiming his superiority over Duran as well. Firstly because he lost all his big fights and secondly because Floyd would never lose to the guys who beat Duran.

It make you wonder do they know of any other boxers besides Ali and Tyson before the 90s

you mean his "big" fights at 147-168! lol

yeah floyd would beat hagler , leonard and hearns.......

[andrewcuff]

lets be honest floyds skills are somewhat overrated too. if you think about it, fighting the opposition floyd does would make anyone look unbeatable.

While he's undoubtedly one of the best fighters of this generation, his skills are sometimes overrated in an ATG sense.

For example, there isn't a single weight division that he's considered #1 ATG or a single boxing attribute that someone hasn't better better at.