How come Paul Williams is rank higher than Miguel Cotto

[T.Horton]

WoW!!!!! i impressed with you, im spelled 1 word wrong, and your all over it like flies on ****. Dont make me own you again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

I am sorry to have to break out the bad language but can anybody be this ******. Go back in this thread and you will see that you were arguing one argument with two different posters. You're the one who is confused. Further, ONE mis-spelled word? Your posts are all disasters. Not that that really means anything because perhaps English is not your second language, granted but you are honestly making an ass of yourself. One guy said that Williams is fighting in three concurrent divisions and another guy said that he is fighting champions. Your convoluted thinking merged both posts and and you responded with one post saying 'which champs Andy Kolle and whoever it was that he fought at 154). Those are not champs'

Get a grip.

[TheSurgeonMDMPH]

**** no!!!!!!!!!!!!!

His skills are height and reach. Wait and see how a old ass and rusty winky will make him look.

the same way a slow ass and sloppy margarito made cotto look! PW vs Cotto = KO in rd 10! Guess who gets ktfo?

[elfag]

How so? Winky is as inactive as they come. Its not as if he's on a hot win streak or something.

Winky would absolutely no doubt be a better win than Cotto's last win.

[T.Horton]

Yea, Cotto's resume at WW is better than Paul's, I don't really see how that could be argued...

Cotto's win over Mosley>Any win that Paul has.

I know man but this is not the 30's, 40's and 50's when the fighters were fighting twice a month. We only have your last performance(s) to go on when ranking fighters nowadays and Paul has looked more impressive at the top of the welter weight division as of late.

Besides, 'Cotto's win over Mosley is better than....' is purely subjective. It could be argued that Cotto fought a much lesser version than the one who faced Margarito.

Anyway, I do see your point and I think that we're just going in circles.

Who do you think ranks higher right now. P4P and at WW.

[TheSurgeonMDMPH]

I know man but this is not the 30's, 40's and 50's when the fighters were fighting twice a month. We only have your last performance(s) to go on when ranking fighters nowadays and Paul has looked more impressive at the top of the welter weight division as of late.

Besides, 'Cotto's win over Mosley is better than....' is purely subjective. It could be argued that Cotto fought a much lesser version than the one who faced Margarito.

Anyway, I do see your point and I think that we're just going in circles.

Who do you think ranks higher right now. P4P and at WW.

PW on both lists by far! Cotto is ok but no where near as good as his fans and the media make him out to be!

[krispy kreme]

Cotto should be rated higher, but I suppose that is debatable, considering Cotto's last opponent.

[Derranged]

Really? I see more people saying they think Williams would beat the **** outta Cotto. I gotta check out that poll.

I think it'd be a really competitive fight. I honestly don't know who I would take.

The poll as I remember had a slight edge for Cotto... I guess the term everyone was misused.

[savorduhflavor]

I know man but this is not the 30's, 40's and 50's when the fighters were fighting twice a month. We only have your last performance(s) to go on when ranking fighters nowadays and Paul has looked more impressive at the top of the welter weight division as of late.

Besides, 'Cotto's win over Mosley is better than....' is purely subjective. It could be argued that Cotto fought a much lesser version than the one who faced Margarito.

Anyway, I do see your point and I think that we're just going in circles.

Who do you think ranks higher right now. P4P and at WW.

Yea, this is a debate that's going always be tight.

I, personally, based on body of work, would put Cotto higher on both lists. But I wouldn't put up a huge argument if Williams was ahead.

If Williams beats Winky, I'd have him over Cotto P4P.

They're both young and have a lot of fighting ahead of them though. I'm just pumped that they exist cause they're both awesome fighters.

[MANGLER]

I like Pwill, but he gets way too much cred for his 154-160 dual existence.

[Steak]

Cotto has a very accomplished record at 140lbs which is often overlooked, has a win over Mosley and a win over Quintana, who holds a win over Williams.

I have no idea why he aint on the p4p lists. just because he lost to Margarito? cmon, thats dumb. I mean, Cotto beat the guy that demolished Margarito.