Question about P4P Ranking????

[savorduhflavor]

But Pavlik lost to an ATG at the end of the day while Cotto didn't

I think the ring title at your weight class is better than a title at other wieght class

I'm just saying what P4P rankings are based off of. Moving up through weight classes makes you P4P...cause it shows how good of a fighter you are regardless of weight.

And I don't think it matters....while Hopkins was a better fighter he was also 43. Pavlik looked like he didn't belong in the ring. He looked like an amateur.

Cotto was very much in the fight against a prime, huge Welterweight. Not that it's even the point, but I definitely think Pavlik's loss was worse.

[Marvelous Floyd]

what list are you talking about? Neither Cotto or Pavlik are on the Ring list.

My bad, they just updated now. Becasue last time I checked Vic D was not on the list

[Great Afrikan]

Pavlik doesnt deserve p4p status, you can't lose 12 rounds and be on the list. At least Cotto tried, i mean he was hitting back you know...

[βetamax]

Pavlik doesnt deserve p4p status, you can't lose 12 rounds and be on the list. At least Cotto tried, i mean he was hitting back you know...

Yea, and Cotto battered Margarito. He was wearing shades for at least 2 weeks after the fight. Margarito showed one of the best displays of chin stability I've ever seen iand you now have to cut a little slack to Cotto because of the glove controversy.

[Spacey1991]

I am unsure to be honest... however if he proves himself in his next few fights against big names he will be put back on it no problem!

[Chunk..]

Am pretty sure Hatton was #7 or #8 in the P4P rankings when he faced #1 Floyd. After he lost, he dropped outside the top 10?

WTF!