In response to the what Calzaghe's resume SHOULD have looked like thread...

[Hook]

Toney spent the next year fighting just 7lbs north of 168.

[ALT=_=Assassin]

Funny how whenever Toney was weight drained Jones fanboys pretend it never happened but as soon as you mention Tarver or Johnson they cry about it being an issue. No double standard there at all

I don't buy Roy's excuse either, he got beat fairly and those were still great wins for Tarver and Johnson.

[Hook]

Funny how whenever Toney was weight drained Jones fanboys pretend it never happened but as soon as you mention Tarver or Johnson they cry about it being an issue. No double standard there at all

Don't buy that line from Jones - certainly not for the Johnson fight - and I'm not a "fan boy" of anyone, unlike your good self.

[Vivid Intent]

I don't buy Roy's excuse either, he got beat fairly and those were still great wins for Tarver and Johnson.

That's fair enough, the weight was an issue though and it effected the fights. Whether they would have beat a 100% Jones is questionable but not out of the question.

[Hook]

That's fair enough, the weight was an issue though and it effected the fights. Whether they would have beat a 100% Jones is questionable but not out of the question.

In your opinon and from what was put out by team Toney.

Toney ALWAYS has weight issues - it's a long standing joke.

He spent the next year after fighting Jones just 7lbs north at 175 - how did he make the weight for those fights?

[Vivid Intent]

In your opinon and from what was put out by team Toney.

Toney ALWAYS has weight issues - it's a long standing joke.

He spent the next year after fighting Jones just 7lbs north at 175 - how did he make the weight for those fights?

He was extremely drained for the Jones fight though. He was having weight issues for his fights prior and the Jones fight was one too far, he then moved up to LHW and spent less than 7 months there before moving up against to CW.

[Hook]

moved up to LHW and spent less than 7 months.

you're making things up now

Over a year after the Jones fight he was still fighting just 7lbs north of the weight he fought Jones at.

[Vivid Intent]

you're making things up now

Over a year after the Jones fight he was still fighting just 7lbs north of the weight he fought Jones at.

Making things up?

That's the truth, he moved up to CW and then back down to LHW for a fight, then back to CW. Clearly a sign of someone with bad weigh management. What's hard to understand? Corrales was weight drained against Mayweather to a lesser extent and still ended up fighting back at the weight. You've clearly no knowledge on what being weight drained is all about.

[bsrizpac]

I wouldn't say that. I've found his posts pretty interesting. Throwing insults around like "you're an idiot" doesn't really constitute a worthwhile comeback to the quality posts he's been writing. No offense. Obviously, the guy isn't an idiot, you just disagree with him.

Pay attention: he started the trash talking.

Just a long winded idiot with an agenda.

[ALT=_=Assassin]

I can't believe this thread went 27 pages......