Who wins the battle of the Nightmares? Peter or Arreola

**Guest** · 02-23-2009, 09:51 PM

Make a poll.

**joe strong** · 02-23-2009, 10:02 PM

Originally posted by mitruth

Arreola is the better boxer no doubt. He has shown that he can get caught and hurt though. Peter packs a decent punch. Vatali showed the Peter can be frustrated and out boxed fairly easily. Both guys have weight/conditioning issues. So who wins and how? (Side note: If the fight was to happen I like Peter's idea of loser changes nickname. That's some WWE stuff right there.)

how do you start a thread?

**M.I Truth ?** · 02-23-2009, 10:06 PM

Originally posted by jreckoning

Make a poll.

True. Done.

**M.I Truth ?** · 02-23-2009, 10:09 PM

Its not Ali vs Frazier but it could be some fun to watch at heavyweight.

**WLAD_OWNS** · 02-23-2009, 10:09 PM

Originally posted by mitruth

Arreola is the better boxer no doubt. He has shown that he can get caught and hurt though. Peter packs a decent punch. Vatali showed the Peter can be frustrated and out boxed fairly easily. Both guys have weight/conditioning issues. So who wins and how? (Side note: If the fight was to happen I like Peter's idea of loser changes nickname. That's some WWE stuff right there.)

I disagree.

Peter is the better fighter. He dominated James Toney, KO'd Maskaev in 6 and beat McCline.

Who has Arreola beat?

**Derranged** · 02-23-2009, 10:09 PM

Its hard to say. Sam Peter has looked like **** lately.. I think if Arreola can make it past the 5th round he'll win..

**Silencers** · 02-23-2009, 10:09 PM

Depends on how much Peter has left.

**joe strong** · 02-23-2009, 10:13 PM

these are the type of fights we need to see in the Hw division.up until the mccline fight I was high on peter but now I think of him as another David izon(bigger thou).he's a puncher who stands in front of you with no head moment & displays marginal defence at best.arreola is very similar but arreola almost looks like he enjoys getting punched.neither guy seems to really improve their skills,they are content with doing what they do now.tua was like that as well(relied on the left hook).they are both 1 dimensional fighters.I say arreola wins by knockout.I can't see in going past 6 rounds.it would be bombs away.it would be nice to see another tua/ibeabuchi like slugfest...arreola within 6

**M.I Truth ?** · 02-23-2009, 10:13 PM

Originally posted by WLAD_OWNS

I disagree.

Peter is the better fighter. He dominated James Toney, KO'd Maskaev in 6 and beat McCline.

Who has Arreola beat?

Good point. Style wise though Arreola seems comfortable using his jab and setting up openings. Peter did look much improved in the second Toney fight but it seemed to me that part of it was that he was willing to out work Toney. Toney just didn't fight for some of those rounds.

Who wins the battle of the Nightmares? Peter or Arreola