this board is incredibaly biased

[120]

to agree with your logic I would have to say that there are bigger fights at 135 for Pac. Floyd being a natural lightweight moving up to fight Deloya at 154 at his strongest weight and beating him doesn't do anything for Floyd's career. there's no difference between the two they are both fighting the fights that makes the most money and nothing else, by the way Ricky is bigger then Floyd.

that's not true, u give me one name in 130/135/140 bigger than hatton and i will respect this. There is no one name that will bump u 20 spots or anything, an ATG list is based on all ur accomplishments not only on who u beat. It also matter on when u beat them and the manner on witch u did. A victory over DLH simply gave him a belt and it was an SD at that. A victory over hatton for Pac would be incredible and knowing the fact and Hatton is the ring champ, has a belt and is his strongest at 140 is really good for Pac overall career.

The situation here is that ATG is not necessarily simply on who u beat but a view on the global scale on witch it happen. Hatton going to 147 and floyd beating him will not be looked on the same way as Pac going into 140 and beating him, that's all

[120]

another thing, DLH strongest era was in the 147 era when he fought mosley

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

This is simple Larry. Le me show you

Manny's Accomplishments
4 division champ
112 WBC title agaisnt- Sasakul
122 IBF titlte against Ledwaba
130 WBC/Ring titles against Marquez
135 WBC title against Diaz

And if Im not mistaken, when he KOd Barrera at 126, was for the Ring title, or Barrera was the ring Champ. Im not sure

Pacquaio's Resume(Ws and Ls)
Chatchia Sasakul, Nedal Hussein, Lehlohonolo Ledwaba, Agapito Sanchez, MAB(x2), Morales(x3), JMM(x2), Oscar Larios, Jorge Solis, David Diaz, ODLH


Floyd's Accomplishments
5 Division Champ
130 WBC title against Hernandez
135 WBC title against Castillo
140 WBC title against Gatti
147 WBC/Ring titles agaisnt Baldomir
154 WBC title against De La Hoya

Floyd's Resume (Ws and Ls)
Hernandez,Gerena, Corrales, Castillo(x2),Chavez, Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, DLH, Hatton,


Manny started at JR FlyWeight and has gone up to WW, wich is the equavalent of Floyd going up, up to LHW. Manny KOd Oscar, and was very dominant in the fight something PBF failed to do.

Plus the Floyds ducking situation and retireing in his prime

I say Manny is like 38 ATG and Floyd is like 52.

No hating!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

[RL_GMA]

i just read if pacman beats hatton it would catipulte him into top 30 static...but floys ko'd hatton and took his 0...i dont wanna hear that 147 **** either.....the hate for floyd is sickening..pacman's resume is not better than floyds...pacman fights oscar and hatton and gets praised..floyd beats them first and gets bashed......pacman have fun with floyds sloppy seconds

Don't be mad homeboy...

Floyd gets a lot of heat because his fights lack any excitement and his opposition choices after he made it big have been some what lack luster. The wins over Oscar and Hatton were great for his resume, but if that's where it ends, he won't be heralded as high (especially if Pacquiao ends up fighting Cotto too...that would be 2 guys Floyd beat AND fighting the one guy Floyd WOULDN'T fight).

Generally, we talk about fights Manny had or is going to have. With Floyd, its comprised a lot of "Would've" or "Could've'. Even you can't deny that.

[larryx]

This is simple Larry. Le me show you

Manny's Accomplishments
4 division champ
112 WBC title agaisnt- Sasakul
122 IBF titlte against Ledwaba
130 WBC/Ring titles against Marquez
135 WBC title against Diaz

And if Im not mistaken, when he KOd Barrera at 126, was for the Ring title, or Barrera was the ring Champ. Im not sure

Pacquaio's Resume(Ws and Ls)
Chatchia Sasakul, Nedal Hussein, Lehlohonolo Ledwaba, Agapito Sanchez, MAB(x2), Morales(x3), JMM(x2), Oscar Larios, Jorge Solis, David Diaz, ODLH


Floyd's Accomplishments
5 Division Champ
130 WBC title against Hernandez
135 WBC title against Castillo
140 WBC title against Gatti
147 WBC/Ring titles agaisnt Baldomir
154 WBC title against De La Hoya

Floyd's Resume (Ws and Ls)
Hernandez,Gerena, Corrales, Castillo(x2),Chavez, Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, DLH, Hatton,


Manny started at JR FlyWeight and has gone up to WW, wich is the equavalent of Floyd going up, up to LHW. Manny KOd Oscar, and was very dominant in the fight something PBF failed to do.

Plus the Floyds ducking situation and retireing in his prime

I say Manny is like 38 ATG and Floyd is like 52.

No hating!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

with what you posted..how is manny 14 spots ahead of floyd???

[PavlikRules]

i just read if pacman beats hatton it would catipulte him into top 30 static...but floys ko'd hatton and took his 0...i dont wanna hear that 147 **** either.....the hate for floyd is sickening..pacman's resume is not better than floyds...pacman fights oscar and hatton and gets praised..floyd beats them first and gets bashed......pacman have fun with floyds sloppy seconds

Pac demolished DLH. Floyd got a gift that could have been a draw. He was running for much of the night.

Floyd is overrated. Get over it.

[120]

with what you posted..how is manny 14 spots ahead of floyd???

competition, manny continued to look for the good challenges while floyd started cherry picking a long time ago

[larryx]

Pac demolished DLH. Floyd got a gift that could have been a draw. He was running for much of the night.

Floyd is overrated. Get over it.

ok you didnt watch that fight then i see..a gift???he was damn near robbed..it was 8-4 at worse...pac fought a weight drained shot oscar

[larryx]

competition, manny continued to look for the good challenges while floyd started cherry picking a long time ago

yea david diaz is the best at 135 right??

[2501]

this board? go take a look at other boards. its no bias, its general opinion by a majority that floyd isn't what his most devoted fans make him out to be.

his fans overrate his wins
his fans overrate his opponents (hatton is now some kind of invinsible beast that can ko Cotto and Pac with ease)