Is Hatton a top 10 P4P?

[Roger Mellie]

19 fighters you would put above of him based on what?

[hammerhiem]

My opinion is that he has been top 10 P4P for the last 4-5 years since the Tzsyu fight basicly.

He's presently 7 on my list after the Calzaghe retirement, If he beats pac I have him moving up above vazquez and marquez who haven't fought in an age but still below Pac.

Pac is coming up 2 weight classes (At least) to take the fight P4P I still think he's better than Hatton.

[boxaholic]

19 fighters you would put above of him based on what?

You where right I only thought of 14 boxers better


1. Pacman
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. Vazquez
4. JMM
5. RMM
6. Calderon
7. Cotto
8. Mosley
9. Vic D.
10. Chad Dawson
11. Pwill
12. Pavlik
13. Abraham
14. Wvladimir Klitchko
15. Ricky Hatton
16. Nate Campbell
17. Nonito Donaire
18. Chris John
19. Kessler
20. Johnson

[hammerhiem]

You where right I only thought of 14 boxers better


1. Pacman
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. Vazquez
4. JMM
5. RMM
6. Calderon
7. Cotto
8. Mosley
9. Vic D.
10. Chad Dawson
11. Pwill
12. Pavlik
13. Abraham
14. Wvladimir Klitchko
15. Ricky Hatton
16. Nate Campbell
17. Nonito Donaire
18. Chris John
19. Kessler
20. Johnson

WTF has Dawson, Pavlik, AA and Pwill done to justify being above hatton?

Guess you have your reasons to hate Hatton but Dawson? fcuk thats your credibility gone.

[boxaholic]

WTF has Dawson, Pavlik, AA and Pwill done to justify being above hatton?

Guess you have your reasons to hate Hatton but Dawson? fcuk thats your credibility gone.

Hatton beat Kostza and deserves the recognition but thats it. Pavlik beat Taylor 2x and lost by going up in weight to try to beat BHOP. By dominating Tarver, edging out Johnson, and dominating Adamek he is in there. Not to mention the unwillingness of Calzaghe and Bhop to fight him gives him immediate credibility. Pwill beat a Plastered up Margarito, AA from the fights we have seen has proven his worth in that top 15 discussion. Hatton lost my respect when he wouldn't fight Junior Witter. I give him props for going after PBF and getting KTFO and took right back after his excuse that Joe Cortez was the reason he lossed. In the last 3 years besides the Paulie Mag win what has he done. Castillo was washed up, Lazcano is not even a top 100 boxer, He arguable lost to Collazo.

[WLAD_OWNS]

Hatton is definitely top 10 p4p, he has a very impressive resume.