Is Hatton a top 10 P4P?

[andrewcuff]

ok..how is williams over hatton and vic???no way in hell

Maybe because Williams is a superior fighter?

[Vast_Aire]

Anywhere 7-15 is where reasonable objective people place him.

Below this you are a hater.
Above this you are a hugger.

Yep. Pretty much.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He sould be number 9 P4P right now. Dont pay attetion to the ring P4P list that is ridiculous.

This is how the P4P list should look.( Maybe a bit off but not as ridiculous as the ring list)

1.Pacquaio
2.JMM
3.B-Hop
4.Calderon
5.Vazquez
6.Mosley
7.Cotto
8.Darchinyan
9.Hatton
10.Marquez

[larryx]

Maybe because Williams is a superior fighter?

and hes proven this how??????????

[andrewcuff]

and hes proven this how??????????

Because Williams hasn't secured any real big fights yet doesn't mean he's not a good fighter.

He's got better movement than Hatton, a much better jab, plus he's actually got head movement.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Because Williams hasn't secured any real big fights yet doesn't mean he's not a good fighter.

He's got better movement than Hatton, a much better jab, plus he's actually got head movement.

Where are the accomplishments men. Williams ,aybe a better fighter than Hatton, but hasnt proven yet.

By your standar I can put JUanma in the Top 10, because Juanma is a beter fighter than Vic, Hatton and possibly Marquez,Vazquez too.

Williams have skills but have done jack **** to prove he is a top P4P fighter!!!!!

[andrewcuff]

Where are the accomplishments men. Williams ,aybe a better fighter than Hatton, but hasnt proven yet.

By your standar I can put JUanma in the Top 10, because Juanma is a beter fighter than Vic, Hatton and possibly Marquez,Vazquez too.

Williams have skills but have done jack **** to prove he is a top P4P fighter!!!!!

I'd put him at #10 because of his skills. Neither he nor Hatton has done jack **** recently, so I think pure boxing ability is as good a barometer as any for these two.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I'd put him at #10 because of his skills. Neither he nor Hatton has done jack **** recently, so I think pure boxing ability is as good a barometer as any for these two.

PW accomplishment
2 time WW champ( No defenses)
Notable Wins
Margarito UD
Quintana TKO1
Phillips TKO8

Notable Loses
Quintana UD

Last Win
A TKO, against a 39 year old Verno Phillips who was like the 4th or 5th SWW


Hatton Accomplishments
2 Division Champion (WBA WW champ) (Unified JWW champ(IBF,WBA), 3 time champ with 6 defenses and the current lineal champ)

Notable wins
Tszyu TKO11
Collazo UD*
Castillo KO4
Urango UD
Maliggnagie TKO11

Notable Loses
Mayweather JR. TKO 10

Last win
a 11 round KO of number 2 rated JWW Paulie Maliggnagie

[Walt Liquor]

I'd put him at #10 because of his skills. Neither he nor Hatton has done jack **** recently, so I think pure boxing ability is as good a barometer as any for these two.

C'mon cuff. You have to accomplish something to get ranked PfP. Dawson would be way higher than PWill in PFP. Pwill would just squeeze into the top 25.

Speaking of Dawson. Where is he in the ring rankings? Caballero is 9 in the ring, Dawson has 4 defenses and has unified titles AND has a win over the Ring cruiserweight champ. Caballero has 7 defenses and a unification over the overrated Molitor. Ring rankings are crazy.

[dans]

Is JMM really gay? what is it with that? I keep hearing that on these forums,and people keep posting pics of him looking slightly mincy.

He seems kind of like he is. I guess we'll never know until he tries to take advantage of someone after a KO.