154 Oscar>147 Cotto?

[Dan...]

IMO the version of Oscar at 154 that fought Floyd is a better fighter than Cotto at 147. And Cotto is probably in my top 3 current favourite fighters.

[sunny31]

This came up in another thread,
so lets hear what BoxingScene thinks.
Is a 154 DLH better than a 147 Cotto?

I was arguing with someone about this on the other thread, and I meant that the de la hoya that fought mayweather (2007 version) is not as good or as a big of a threat as cotto would be now, considering margarito hasn't ruined him.

[savorduhflavor]

IMO the version of Oscar at 154 that fought Floyd is a better fighter than Cotto at 147. And Cotto is probably in my top 3 current favourite fighters.

I slightly disagree with that. It's close though.

The DLH that fought Mayorga? Definitely better.

[IwatchBoxing]

Cotto would destory DLH, prime or not at both 147 and 154....

[MELLY-MEL...]

Cotto would destory DLH, prime or not at both 147 and 154....

prime? no way! prime 4 prime odlh ko's cotto. i love miguel, but it's true.

[IwatchBoxing]

prime? no way! prime 4 prime odlh ko's cotto. i love miguel, but it's true.

Just how his papi did, Sugar Shane, oh yeah its true....DLH is overrated as ***. How can he be top 50 ATG

[AntonTheMeh]

I don't think easy. I mean maybe Cotto, but Oscar in 2007 was a lot better then the version that fought Cotto. He was faster and had way better reflexes.

oscar ****** by then.he was horrible.that fight ws "close" becuase of the **** he got a way with(sticking his elbow in floyd's throat, while punching) and what floyd didn't do( being economical, and not taking chances)

[AntonTheMeh]

IMO the version of Oscar at 154 that fought Floyd is a better fighter than Cotto at 147. And Cotto is probably in my top 3 current favourite fighters.

because he beat mayorga?

[MELLY-MEL...]

Just how his papi did, Sugar Shane, oh yeah its true....DLH is overrated as ***. How can he be top 50 ATG

no point debating with you if your gonna act 3 yrs old. prime oscar was right there with a prime mosley, while cotto squeaked a ud by a far past it shane. you wanna talk triangle theories use that as an example than. obviously youdon'twatchboxing!!!!

[ELHURACAN58]

prime? no way! prime 4 prime odlh ko's cotto. i love miguel, but it's true.

Why must you doubt Cotto!? He will destroy the none Believers!!