154 Oscar>147 Cotto?

[Bad~JuJu]

This came up in another thread,
so lets hear what BoxingScene thinks.
Is a 154 DLH better than a 147 Cotto?

[chibomber]

10 years ago oscar yes. Now no, and even so Cotto is not done yet at 147 so its not even fair to say oscar is better at 54

[dde91]

Have to see what Cotto is going to do this year. Oscar at 154 lost to Mosley, Mayweather and beat Vargas, Mayorga.

Cotto beat at 147 Mosley, Judah.

But Cotto could do a lot more in the next year and a half

[Bad~JuJu]

10 years ago oscar yes. Now no, and even so Cotto is not done yet at 147 so its not even fair to say oscar is better at 54

Someone stated that the Oscar who fought floyd is better than current Cotto.

[warp1432]

Definietly the version that fought Vargas. Maybe the version that fought Mayweather and Mayorga too.

[oc9979]

if you talking about cotto and de la hoya right now. or last year if they step in the ring cotto would outbox the crap out of de la hoya. but a prime de la hoya would outbox anyone

[Lucky Charms]

Now, Cotto. Years ago I'd take Oscar.

[AntonTheMeh]

NOPE.maybe years ago.the one that fought floyd? get the **** outta here.not even close.
cotto.easily.

[Dan...]

Do you mean would De la Hoya at 154 beat Miguel at 147? If so, of course he would.

[warp1432]

NOPE.maybe years ago.the one that fought floyd? get the **** outta here.not even close.
cotto.easily.

I don't think easy. I mean maybe Cotto, but Oscar in 2007 was a lot better then the version that fought Cotto. He was faster and had way better reflexes.