Shouldn't Calzaque be considered a better fighter than mayweather?

[The Gambler1981]

wohoo! im not alone!

No one is ever alone when it comes to talking bad about Floyd Mayweather Jr. There will always be someone to back up that point of view, he is a polarizing figure no one is indifferent on him.

[boxasmash]

calzaghe is a lot better than mayweather is every department, dont expect many people on this board to agree with you though.

we have an influx of afro americans with a chip on their shoulders.

[thebowtod]

Calzaghe in his 20 was fighting who exactly?? The great uan Carlos Gimenez Ferreyra


Calzaghe best win till today is a questionable point decision over Hopkins who knocked him down at the age of 43

why does it matter how old he is? Bernard doesn't aged or slow or punch drunk, cuz he barely gets hit. lol, hopkins fights like he is 30. One thing is for sure though, at least calzaque didn't retire to avoid possible chances of losing.

[Sugar May Floyd]

why does it matter how old he is? Bernard doesn't aged or slow or punch drunk, cuz he barely gets hit. lol, hopkins fights like he is 30. One thing is for sure though, at least calzaque didn't retire to avoid possible chances of losing.

Really??? Chad Dawson?? Anyone. Got out of the Glen Johnson fight how many times.

If Mayweather did retire avoiding possible, how cine he has a better resume and fought more prime fighters

[Sugar May Floyd]

calzaghe is a lot better than mayweather is every department, dont expect many people on this board to agree with you though.

we have an influx of afro americans with a chip on their shoulders.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=193590&highlight=Race

Right......

There are more latino and whites than blacks on these forums

[AceNguyen]

Is this thread a joke? You can say that you think Calzaghe is better than Mayweather(I wouldn't agree), but you can't even begin to compare resumes.

Even Floyd's lesser wins against Jesus Chavez or Zab Judah would probably be Joe's third or fourth best wins.

[Owlzfan84]

They both left a lot of questions unanswered. I respect Calzaghe more as a fighter, because he at least would take risks inside the ring and engage, but at the end of the day, Floyd's got the edge on resume.

[Sugar May Floyd]

They both left a lot of questions unanswered. I respect Calzaghe more as a fighter, because he at least would take risks inside the ring and engage, but at the end of the day, Floyd's got the edge on resume.

Interesting, Floyd took less risk.

Moved up 5 weight class.
Fought more prime fighter.
Got outweighed most of the time, sometimes even by 16 pounds

Yet took less risk than Calzaghe

[M.I Truth ?]

why does it matter how old he is? Bernard doesn't aged or slow or punch drunk, cuz he barely gets hit. lol, hopkins fights like he is 30. One thing is for sure though, at least calzaque didn't retire to avoid possible chances of losing.

Its much easier to make a thread that just says you don't like Mayweather. More people would agree with you and you would be saying something truthful. Those two things are lacking in this thread.

[thebowtod]

Really??? Chad Dawson?? Anyone. Got out of the Glen Johnson fight how many times.

If Mayweather did retire avoiding possible, how cine he has a better resume and fought more prime fighters

ok let me list the fighters he ducked,

Mosley
Cotto
Pacman