Did you Have Castillo beating Mayweather for the first fight?

[thebowtod]

Exactly, its a mind ****, because HBO screamed robbery, the moron haters screamed robbery.

Id love someone to show me all these clean shots floyd was getting hit with in that fight.

The majority of the first 6 rounds at least are clearly mayweather rounds, then castillo got deducted a point too.

Some people honestly cant tell the difference between blocked and landed punches or love giving rounds to a fighter just for moving forwards.

i can honestly tell you floyd didn't land jack except a jab to the body in the first 6 rounds.

[THE REED]

If JLC wanted a decision in the first fight he should have started comming on sooner then round 6. If you give away 5 of the first 6 rounds, it is extraordinerly hard to win a decision, when you consider the subjective nature of judging.

Floyd just DIDNT do enough IMO... It reminded me of the Joe Calzaghe-Bernard fight...

Floyd/Bernard just didnt do enough to get the win IMO

[Technical_Skill]

i can honestly tell you floyd didn't land jack except a jab to the body in the first 6 rounds.

So how did you score the first 6 rounds then, who did you give them to?

[thebowtod]

Floyd just DIDNT do enough IMO... It reminded me of the Joe Calzaghe-Bernard fight...

Floyd/Bernard just didnt do enough to get the win IMO

i dont think he did enough either.

[thebowtod]

So how did you score the first 6 rounds then, who did you give them to?

i gave 4 to mayweather and two to castillo.

[Technical_Skill]

i gave 4 to mayweather and two to castillo.

So you gave 4 out of the first 6 rounds to mayweather.

Now castillo got deducted a point during a round, (which i personally had going to mayweather anyways) so if you give that round to mayweather.....

Then he has won at least 5 rounds?, and that assuming castillo clearly won the other 7 (not the case, unless you cant score boxing)

Does a fighter Winning at least 5/12 rounds indicate a close fight or a robbery?

[thebowtod]

So you gave 4 out of the first 6 rounds to mayweather.

Now castillo got deducted a point during a round, (which i personally had going to mayweather anyways) so if you give that round to mayweather.....

Then he has won at least 5 rounds?, and that assuming castillo clearly won the other 7 (not the case, unless you cant score boxing)

Does a fighter Winning at least 5/12 rounds indicate a close fight or a robbery?

sorry me 3 to 3, i screwed up, but hell, i cant get to mad, after all its just a fight.

[S A M U R A I]

I had Castillo winning the fight... Ive watched it about 5-6 times.... And Floyd just didnt do enough.

Yup, same as reed. I also saw it maybe 5 or 6 times and always came to the same conclusion.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[The Gambler1981]

Floyd just DIDNT do enough IMO... It reminded me of the Joe Calzaghe-Bernard fight...

Floyd/Bernard just didnt do enough to get the win IMO

Judging fights live and from a TV set are very very different. Especially if you have the sound on or can not disregard the various grapics that come up.

I will stand by what I said JLC did jack **** in the first 6 rounds, he was lucky to win one on my scorecard and he did not sweep the last half of the fight. Very hard to win a decision like that epecially if you get a point taken away from you in a round you were losing, if you do not get knockdowns anyways.

To me it is pretty simple there is almost no way Mayweather could have lost a decision when you take everything into account about the fight.

[THE REED]

Judging fights live and from a TV set are very very different. Especially if you have the sound on or can not disregard the various grapics that come up.

I will stand by what I said JLC did jack **** in the first 6 rounds, he was lucky to win one on my scorecard and he did not sweep the last half of the fight. Very hard to win a decision like that epecially if you get a point taken away from you in a round you were losing, if you do not get knockdowns anyways.

To me it is pretty simple there is almost no way Mayweather could have lost a decision when you take everything into account about the fight.

well, thats your opinion and your entitled to it... but about 65% of the forum disagrees with you.