The Oscar that faced Manny vs the Tony that faced Shane???

[El Chicano]

Not sure....I have a feeling DLH could pull it off. Remember that Pacquaio is a much smaller and fast, agile target. He quit and collapsed out of frustration. Margarito is much slower and straight up, he's a 147 lb. Pavlik. Plus Oscar is arguably just as big as Margarito. DLH would win but would have to work.

I really would have liked to see them fight about 4-5 years ago.

[The Gully Gad]

I think i would actually want margarito to have the loaded hand wraps for this one

[MANGLER]

Marg woulda knocked his ass out, plain wrapped.

[SickmyDuck]

Margarito would have stopped him

[street bully]

Margarito TKO 5.
Oscar doen't stand in front of you and force he fight like Molsey does.

[El Chicano]

So as crappy as Tony looked on Saturday, he still woulda KO'd crappy Oscar?

Are we saying that practically anybody at Welter woulda KO'd Oscar that night?

If that's the case, does it discredit Manny's victory against crappy Oscar?

[Piper the Great]

tony by ko.

tony at least landed some shots even shane admitted that. oscar on the other hand didnt land ****.

[street bully]

tony by ko.

tony at least landed some shots even shane admitted that. oscar on the other hand didnt land ****.

Shane also stated that he felt the few punches Tony landed cleanly.