The Oscar that faced Manny vs the Tony that faced Shane???

[El Chicano]

Who wins at 147lbs? How & why???

[larryx]

i think 99.9 percent of welters would beat this oscar at 147..anyway margo ko's him even without the plaster..damn shane wouldve ****d oscar

[aether]

their opponents have significant speed advantage and respectable power. both of them got their ass whooped. that's why they looked crappy

[egreezy]

Both shoulda fought @154...may have looked great against slower bigger opponents

[Ido]

Oscar would cheat off Moesly. Pop him twice and clinch.

You guys do understand that the reason why, Marg applies pressure is because he can take a punch and move forward…to corner his opponent. Yet he still depends on distance to land his wild hooks and uppers? Those punches need leverage, to become heavy handed and distance to throw 100 plus punches per round.

Moesly used a beautiful yet simple strategy. Get a few free shots (and make them count), and cut off his distance by neutralizing his arm (the clinch). It happened over and over again, and you get a battered and worn out fighter

[Silencers]

Margarito would have won.

[gibo]

Oscar would cheat off Moesly. Pop him twice and clinch.

You guys do understand that the reason why, Marg applies pressure is because he can take a punch and move forward…to corner his opponent. Yet he still depends on distance to land his wild hooks and uppers? Those punches need leverage, to become heavy handed and distance to throw 100 plus punches per round.

Moesly used a beautiful yet simple strategy. Get a few free shots (and make them count), and cut off his distance by neutralizing his arm (the clinch). It happened over and over again, and you get a battered and worn out fighter

yeah, like he cheated him twice...

[-Antonio-]

I dont think Oscar is capable of executing the game plan Mosley did at this point. I also dont think he's game enough physically or mentally.

[AztecWanker]

how would oscar beat margarito?

[MikeBrew328]

Not sure....I have a feeling DLH could pull it off. Remember that Pacquaio is a much smaller and fast, agile target. He quit and collapsed out of frustration. Margarito is much slower and straight up, he's a 147 lb. Pavlik. Plus Oscar is arguably just as big as Margarito. DLH would win but would have to work.