who has gone 5 divisions and dominated every division???

[Left Hook Tua]

Frietas and casamoyer where at 135 when he was at 135 not 130. they didn't want it. Zoo lost to hatton and retired. Harris lost to Maussa. Hatton didn't want it and #3 Cotto didn't want it. 147 at the time Cotto and maragrito wheren't ranked over Baldmoir or accomplished what Baldomir accomplished at 147 at the time. Mosley could have had the fight, but tooth was hurting. what else u got !!!

freitas and casamayor was #3 and #4 at 130 around 2000 when floyd and diego was #1 and #2.

when floyd beat diego freitas and casa jumped to #2 and #3 behind #1 floyd.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

beating 2 lineal champs back to back isnt good enough cause its floyd

the lineal title is given by The Ring. Who is no better than WBC,WBO or IBF, for that matter. If you think Baldomir was better, than Mosley, Cotto or Magarito at that time you are a fool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[larryx]

the lineal title is given by The Ring. Who is no better than WBC,WBO or IBF, for that matter. If you think Baldomir was better, than Mosley, Cotto or Magarito at that time you are a fool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

when you get through he beat both of the lineal champs back to back

[hammerhiem]

People who PBF COULD have fought @ 135-147 during the time he was in those divisions.

135: Castillio, Johnson, Spadafora, Lazcano. all four where top 5 when he got into the division and top 5 when he left.

140: Tzsyu, Gatti, Hatton, Cotto, Mitchell. See above.

147: Judah, Margarito, Baldomir, Cotto.

Now thats not a bad record IMHO.

[Left Hook Tua]

beating 2 lineal champs back to back isnt good enough cause its floyd

how the hell did he beat 2 lineal champs back to back?

hello. zab lost the lineal title to baldomir before floyd fought him.

therefore he was not the lineal champ anymore.

he beat 1 lineal champ that was baldo.

shane couldn't beat forrest who couldn't beat mayorga who couldn't beat spinks who lost to zab who laid an egg against baldomir.

from 2002-2006 , a space of 4-5 years there was SEVEN lineal champs at 147.

[IMDAZED]

People who PBF COULD have fought @ 135-147 during the time he was in those divisions.

135: Castillio, Johnson, Spadafora, Lazcano. all four where top 5 when he got into the division and top 5 when he left.

140: Tzsyu, Gatti, Hatton, Cotto, Mitchell. See above.

147: Judah, Margarito, Baldomir, Cotto.

Now thats not a bad record IMHO.

Agreed. But please note he never fought Hatton and Mitchell at 140. So you have to ask yourself where do those two fighters rank at welter, where he fought them.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

when you get through he beat both of the lineal champs back to back

The only good win for Mayweather at 147 was judah!!!!!!!!!! At 140 he dindt have any, nor at 154.

Floyd good wins per division
At 130
Hernandez
Chavez
Corrales
Gerena

at 135
Castillo
Sosa

140
Corley
Gatti

at 147
Judah
Hatton

at 154 Oscar

Now big wins by division

at 130
Corrales

at 135
Castilllo

At 140
errrrrr

at 147
errrrrrrrrrr

at 154
errrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[deevel79]

he had to be the smallest welter and gets 0 credit..but he was the kingpin

Yeah, because beating Baldomir makes u a kingpin!

[cueball66]

if floyd beat kostya at 140, then beat judah while he was the champ at 147, and then fought oscar at 154, and retired you wouldn't have so many people bitching. you would have more people proping him up as the greatest, and you would have fewer uninformed fanboys arguing other wise.but ever since floyd got to 140, it was more about the money.which is why he fough gatti in jersey, who couldn't beat floyd if floyd fought with one arm.

so you admit he pussied out of a fight with the real 140 champ?
btw to imply that by pointing this fact out that it makes me(& many others)
an "uninformed fanboy" is just pathetic self-delusional nut-hugg behavior!!
yes i would give floyd more respect if he fought tszyu! but he didnt! that is the point!!

[MANGLER]

Dude didn't want it wit tough WW comp. The excuse cats use for this is they didn't bring enuf $. The guy said himself he got more $ than he could ever spend, so why use that excuse not to fight good fighters in your division, all of whom you'd be favored to beat? This argument is tired, and it's pointless since Mr boat buyer is retired now. Cats really need to stop bringin him up all the damn time.