Did Mayweather really dominate all the divisions he was champion in?

[cortdawg25]

Floyd Mayweather Jr. is a great fighter and he has a good resume.

He also was arguably the best fighter in most of the divisions he fought in but I see it posted a lot on here that he ruled every single division he was in or he dominated every division he was in except 154.

I don't agree.

He was certainly the best in those divisions and at super featherweight and lightweight he certainly beat the next best fighter in the division but did he really dominate and clean out any division?

Did he even clean out 130 and 135 let alone any division above that?

he cleaned out 130, but u don't have to clean out a division to dominate. in every weight class he has been, he became the best fighter in the division. 135 beat the man twice and koed an undefeated Ndou who was knocking everyone out at the time. 140, destroyed Gatti and all the other top fighters ran scared, 147 became the lineal ww champ. now u can say he didn't dominate 147, but he clearly was the best there.

[larryx]

Oscar Won titles in 6 divsions and he fought the best in each division, or atleast people that were rank high!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

oscar did not dominate every division he fought at..

[cortdawg25]

Let's start at 130......

He beat Genaro Hernandez for his 130 belt in 1998. He was 130 champion from 1998-2002.

In those 4 years or so he only fought 2 top ranked super featherweights.

Genaro when he beat him for the title and Diego Corrales who was ranked #2 behind him and in some years ranked #1 above him.

For a couple of years there Joel Casamayor and Acelino Freitas was ranked right there behind Floyd Mayweather and obviously fights with those 2 were never made.

Would you consider Floyd's run at 130 dominant or considered it cleaning out the division?

casamoyer and freitas was at 135 when he took the belt from Castillo. also carlos hernandez was top 10 ranked at 130 along with angel manfredy, jesus chavez

[larryx]

He still fought the best. Something Mayweather can say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

at 130 Not so good
Breadahl
Campanella

at 135
Paez
Molina
Ruelas
Hernandez
Leija

at 140
Gonzalez
Chavez

at 147
Whitaker
Camacho
Rivera
Chavez
Quartey
Carr
Trinidad
Mosley x2
Pacquiao(Oscar advantage)

at 154
Campas
Vargas
Mayorga
Mayweather(Altough it was OScar advantage)

at 160
Sturm
Hopkins

See the difference!!!!!!

the thread said dominated not lost

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

oscar did not dominate every division he fought at..

Where or when did i said that he dominate every division??
He fought the best fighters in every division he fought. Mayweather cant say that!!

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

the thread said dominated not lost

Yeah becauyse Floyd would of gone undefeted through Oscar resume!!!!!

[larryx]

Yeah becauyse Floyd would of gone undefeted through Oscar resume!!!!!

no he wouldnt have never said that..you replied to my post and said oscar went 6..tua said did floyd dominate every division..no1 has dominated 5 to 6 divisions its impossible and asking alot

[IMDAZED]

He still fought the best. Something Mayweather can say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

at 130 Not so good
Breadahl
Campanella

at 135
Paez
Molina
Ruelas
Hernandez
Leija

at 140
Gonzalez
Chavez

at 147
Whitaker
Camacho
Rivera
Chavez
Quartey
Carr
Trinidad
Mosley x2
Pacquiao(Oscar advantage)

at 154
Campas
Vargas
Mayorga
Mayweather(Altough it was OScar advantage)

at 160
Sturm
Hopkins

See the difference!!!!!!

What type of bull**** is this? Man, he lost about half the fights you listed. And you never mentioned who he won his titles againsts. What you think this list is supposed to prove? GTFOH

[IMDAZED]

Floyd was the man at 130 and 135.

Oscar was never the man in any division, maybe 154 briefly when he beat Vargas and even that's debateable.

[cortdawg25]

at 135 he could have fought casamoyer and freitas, but neither showed interest.

at 140, he could have fought Cotto, Hatton, Zoo, or harris. Cotto and Hatton wanted none of him. zoo lost to hatton and retired. Harris lost to Maussa.

at 147, he could have fought Cotto and mosley. margarito was a nobody, williams was to green as well as quintana, Berto. Collazo was unknown and damn near lost to hatton.

at 154, he could have fought Spinks, Karmazin, Mayorga, and man from Africa..I forget his name.

u can't blame him for 140 and Cotto at 147 would have happened if not for oscar wanting a rematch and trying to pull his penis out in negotiation which caused him to retire along with the criticism and hatred of the media and so-called pundits. at 154, he is too small...but for the guape he can go up there and get a W