Is Mayweather THE best fighter ever? - i say should be Higher than SRR

[Lazy Liberal]

Even tho i know i will get blasted.. i'd say a prime DLH is greater then Mosley.

Prime Oscar is better than Mosley.

[Fox McCloud]

He has the best resume in the world. he is undefeated for ****s sake!

He's tied with this guy:

http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php...5692&cat=boxer

I don't know anything about SRR.
I can only go by what I heard.

But looking at his record. If you consider that most of his losses came when he was past his best (and his best we don't even have video footage of, because it was at 147lbs.) He is without question the best fighter ever in his prime.
He was a monster.

95 fights in a row without a loss, the only person Chavez's start to his career couldn't beat. That's saying something.

Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses, he ranks among the likes of Ross Puritty, Roberto Duran, Emmanuel Augustus and Carlos Baldomir who also have many losses.

Putting him above Ross Purity is pretty generous.

[hammerhiem]

No, just No, it's not even close.

Floyd skill wise might get top ten but overall P4P he's only just top 20.

[Ryn0]

He has the best resume in the world. he is undefeated for ****s sake!

Hopkins has a better resume than Mayweather

Hopkins: Pavlik, Wright, DLH, Tarver, Tito, Joppy, Holmes, Johnson

Mayweather: Hatton, DLH, Judah, Baldo, Castillo, Chavez, Corrales

[larryx]

this is a bait hate thread people dont respond seriously....by the way no margo's the best ever

[boxasmash]

yes, he should move up to heavyweight and beat wladimir klitschko with his raw speed.

[Chups]

I mean this guy is unbelievable, impenetrable defense, genuis in the ring, the slickest, fastest, fighter ever lived. UNDEFEATED, never ducked anyone. i think this guy the best boxer in the world. He is higher in ATG ranking than Sugar Ray Robinson. anyone agree with me?

He actually have the weakest resume among the ATGs.

His ATG status come from being the best fighter in his time, his FOTY awards and his 5 time champ in 5 different Divisions.

[Fox McCloud]

Hopkins has a better resume than Mayweather

Hopkins: Pavlik, Wright, DLH, Tarver, Tito, Joppy, Holmes, Johnson

Mayweather: Hatton, DLH, Judah, Baldo, Castillo, Chavez, Corrales

Hopkins and Pacquaio both have resumes that are better than Mayweather right now... no question in my mind.

Trinidad might have a more solid resume too, he fought a lot of good fighters on his way up.

[boxasmash]

No, just No, it's not even close.

Floyd skill wise might get top ten but overall P4P he's only just top 20.

no where near top 20, closer to 60-70.

[1toTHADOME]

ARE YOU ****IN JOKIN????? FLoyd ducked Cotto, Williams, Margarito, Clotty, Mosley, and now Pac. He is a joke. He is an all time great but not no where near SRR. Mosley is higher all time great then Gayweather and so is Pac.

EXACTLY! him being undefeated doesn't mean ****. his resume is alright but he shouldn't have sealed it so early.