Whose really the top 2 guys at WW, let alone one

[Kris Silver]

It's getting increasingly difficult to really know for sure who the the top 2 guys are at WW, let alone one. It's mad;

-Floyd's retired and even then hasn't faced a couple of key top guys.

-Cotto got beat by Margarito.

-Just when we thought Margarito might be the top guy Mosely pulls and upset and beats him.

-But wait, Paul Williams beat Margarito, and few were talking of Mosley being the man at WW.

-And even then Cotto beat Mosley.


To top it off Pacman has an impressive win at WW pretty much, and has talked of facing say Marg, maybe now someone else. He's seen as a close fight for Mayweather too.



****'s like a soap seriously. And then just one division, 7 lbs lower it's completely different in that there's clearly an agreed top guy significantly above anyone else.

Anyone find this **** head ****ingly confusing and annoying?

[120]

1-mosley
2-cotto(after beating jennings)
3-margarito
4-clottey
5-berto

[jmmfan]

It basically boils down to opinion, for exactly the reasons you listed really...

[McAlister]

1-mosley
2-cotto(after beating jennings)
3-margarito
4-clottey
5-berto

marg dont need to be up there no more

I say

Mosley
Cotto
Clottey
Berto

[Kris Silver]

I just can't get over how events have turned out leaving this the situation as it is. And that is, were getting further and further away from any kind of consensus on who really is the best fighter at WW.

And further more, I include Pacman, Williams and even Hatton in this. Might sound off but when one of those guys can quickly and easily have the next fight at WW and beat some of the guys it makes it even more confusing as to at WW, who is the best.

Mix up all these styles and each guys get some wins and losses. Yet that's not anywhere near as true of most other divisions. It's crazy.

[120]

marg dont need to be up there no more

I say

Mosley
Cotto
Clottey
Berto

why not, he did beat clottey and cotto

[McAlister]

why not, he did beat clottey and cotto

theres speculations of foul play... I dont give him credit for that

[Kris Silver]

See, 5 posts in and were already arguing about putting one guy over another.

WW is the most popular division understandably so, but sometimes you wonder how much of that is due to the amount of guys and complexity of it all, leaving loads of speculation and talking points, growing it's popularity. Is it better to have a division like this, or like LWW where there's a clear top guy? Is one or the other boring or annoying for it?

[ScofieldBurrows]

I will give massive, massive props to anybody who cleans out the division and i think everyone else will too. I don't think you can put Mosley ahead of Cotto on the list since Cotto beat Shane. Can you put Williams in a list but am not sure if he qualifies as a welter? They should have a tournament but it would take about 3 years considering the number of fighters in and around the division.

[120]

ok, u'r asking for 1 and 2

mosley
cotto