Where would Hatton stand (P4P) if he beats Manny?

[hammerhiem]

This is an odd post. I didn't say EVER that I don't respect Hatton, so I'm not sure where you got that "respect" comment from. I don't understand why anyone would want a fighter to die either. That's just bizarre to me. People who say **** like that are worthless pieces of garbage.

Go and have a look at the Hatton threads, Ricky is basicly being given no chance and you are going to get 10 threads a day titled "What round will Hatton be stopped"

Pacman is coming up 2 weights to fight a guy who's been stopped once and it took PBF a better fighter at 147 than manny is at 140 to do it.

Hatton has week chin and Pacquiao will KO him in 5!

My opinion changed from 11, then 9, then 5.

i would be shocked if pac don't stop ricky within 10

P4P does not mean you can beat anyone at any weight and Hatton at 140 is in a different league to the ODLH Manny fought.

[Brother Naazim]

If Hatton beats Pacman then I'd put Calzaghe at #1 and Hatton at #2.

I always knew you were an idiot. Thanks for proving it.

[badboypeenoy]

I don't see it happening, but if Hatton wins, where does he stand in P4P rankings?

Depends on how he beats Pacquiao. He wins by split decision he gets to around number 8; unanimous decision or by a flash KO in a fight where he is behind on points, probably 6 or 7 depending on how Cotto and Margarito performs; Hatton wins by KO in a fight where he dominates Pacquiao, I'd say within 5; if he gives Pacquiao a total beatdown, probably around 3 or 4 depending on how Marquez takes care of Diaz. Number 3 behind Calzaghe and Marquez would be the highest I can see him in. Pacquiao on the otherhand, depending on how he loses will slip from 2 to number 4 in the top 10 P4P list.

Tito Trinidad won over then number one Dela Hoya and he only slid up from #4 to #3 I think. But knowing how Brits have this thing about exaggerating wins by Brit fighters, Hatton would probably be knighted by the Queen.

[hammerhiem]

But knowing how Brits have this thing about exaggerating wins by Brit fighters, Hatton would probably be knighted by the Queen.

Hatton will probaby be knighted at some point anyway, even if he losses badly, we respect our top sportmen win or lose.

[BetterCallSaul]

If Hatton beats the no1, he is the no1. Considering he is top 10 already.

[Roger Mellie]

midway in the top ten.it wouldnt be that big a win for ricky.p4p doesnt mean p4p literally,and busting up midgets aint that much of an achievement.

[2-smooth]

he should stay in the same place

only way hatton can win is by mauling and holding pacquiao and that doesn't deserve a spot in the p4p ranks

[BetterCallSaul]

midway in the top ten.it wouldnt be that big a win for ricky.p4p doesnt mean p4p literally,and busting up midgets aint that much of an achievement.

It is a big acheivement when 99% of people are tipping him to lose.

Hatton would be the no1 p4p if he wins. Hatton beating Manny, is bigger than Cotto beating Margarito, Calzaghe beating Dawson, Marquez beating Diaz.

The only way I could put somebody above him, is if the winner of Margarito vs Cotto 2, beat Paul Williams.

[Roger Mellie]

It is a big acheivement when 99% of people are tipping him to lose.

Hatton would be the no1 p4p if he wins. Hatton beating Manny, is bigger than Cotto beating Margarito, Calzaghe beating Dawson, Marquez beating Diaz.

The only way I could put somebody above him, is if the winner of Margarito vs Cotto 2, beat Paul Williams.

I know timba.Its after lunch and i'm feeling a bit mischievous

[Roger Mellie]

In all seriousness,I struggle with this whole concept of him being No.1 because of three words-Juan Manuel Marquez