How Many ATGs Has Floyd Beaten???

[catalinul]

The only ATG on his resume would be de la Hoya,and Oscar is arguably not an ATG.

[Mr. Fantastic]

floyd had beaten alot of solid fighters..atg's????naw

Ty for your answer. Another one is, why is he viewed as really great at 135??

[Chups]

Floyd has beaten future HOF'ers, but no ATG's.

And that would still be Oscar DLH and nobody else.

Although Castillo and Diego gave us amazing fights......they will never be HOF.

[larryx]

Ty for your answer. Another one is, why is he viewed as really great at 135??

floyd is viewed as great because of his skill set and the fact that he did win titles in 5 weight classes-not exactly easy all while going undefeated..no he didnt fight any atg..but he is an atg

[Lazy Liberal]

as long as a fighter stays undefeated, his fans will make the case for his greatness. Even if his opponents are stiffs and weak, his fans will go to their grave believing Floyd was the greatest of all time.

I challenge anyone to make the case that Floyds opponents were the toughest and therefore he is worthy of being heralded as the greatest of all time.No way Floyd the toughest guys out there, no way his comp compares to Oscar's. Oscar would be undefeated if he fought Floyd's comp, ..........real deal!

[larryx]

And that would still be Oscar DLH and nobody else.

Although Castillo and Diego gave us amazing fights......they will never be HOF.

man chico and castillo will def be in the hall of fame along with ricky hatton

[larryx]

as long as a fighter stays undefeated, his fans will make the case for his greatness. Even if his opponents are stiffs and weak, his fans will go to their grave believing Floyd was the greatest of all time.

I challenge anyone to make the case that Floyds opponents were the toughest and therefore he is worthy of being heralded as the greatest of all time.No way Floyd the toughest guys out there, no way his comp compares to Oscar's. Oscar would be undefeated if he fought Floyd's comp, ..........real deal!

floyd didnt fight bums now..thats over exagerating..there werent atf's but were good fighters..floyd is great anyone with eyes can see how great a fighter he is

[Chups]

man chico and castillo will def be in the hall of fame along with ricky hatton

Forgot about Ricky........yes Ricky will be a HOF.....I don't think DC and JLC will.

[Pullcounter]

And why is he considered so great at 135 by Floyd fans??

how many ATGs were around when floyd wasnt retired?

[Bhopreign]

People are fickle, do you know what the term all time great means? Its not a term you just throw around, there arnt many. Therefore you will be lucky to have an all time great just happening to be floating around in your weight class during your career, there were no all time great lightweights at 135 when Floyd was there. What all time greats have there been while Floyd has even been fighting.