How Many ATGs Has Floyd Beaten???

[eazy_mas]

Floyd has beaten future HOF'ers, but no ATG's.

I agree with that.

Many HOFers even come out to become a HOF long time after they retire.

[Mr. Fantastic]

floyd is viewed as great because of his skill set and the fact that he did win titles in 5 weight classes-not exactly easy all while going undefeated..no he didnt fight any atg..but he is an atg

His skills are good no doubt. Props on the 5 weight classes....DLH has 6, one more than Floyd, and yet he's not an ATG?? Other than the Pac fight, his losses did really look like he lost(except Hopkins & Sturm).

I'm still curious on how he is considered an ATG at 135.

[Lazy Liberal]

floyd didnt fight bums now..thats over exagerating..there werent atf's but were good fighters..floyd is great anyone with eyes can see how great a fighter he is

He is great, very skilled and worthy of praise, but i dont fall for that"Greatest of all time" talk.

Gotta admit that his title at 140 and 147 were rather suspect. GAtti was called a paper champ by Floyd, Gatti was champ cause Tzsyu was stripped. At 147, Floyd hit the lottery when Baldomir became champ, Vernon Forrest would later go on to beat Baldomir, so make what u want of it. Yes, he won, but questioning his fights is not hating.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Oscar would be undefeated if he fought Floyd's comp, ..........real deal!

I agree with this 100%. Winning belts in 5 weight classes is still really good though.

[catalinul]

Forgot about Ricky........yes Ricky will be a HOF.....I don't think DC and JLC will.

Castillo is a HOFer already,most likely Corrales is himself,not first ballot but HOFer,at least in my view.

[larryx]

His skills are good no doubt. Props on the 5 weight classes....DLH has 6, one more than Floyd, and yet he's not an ATG?? Other than the Pac fight, his losses did really look like he lost(except Hopkins & Sturm).

I'm still curious on how he is considered an ATG at 135.

oscar did win 6 divisions..but floyd did 5 undefeated

[Lazy Liberal]

I agree with this 100%. Winning belts in 5 weight classes is still really good though.

The only guy who would possibly be a tough fight would be ..........well....damn, no one.

The only guy would be Castillo at 135, he was kinda like a mini chavez in some ways, but Oscar handled the real chavez twice, other than that, Oscar would be undefeated.

[Lazy Liberal]

oscar did win 6 divisions..but floyd did 5 undefeated

Would Floyd go through Oscar's resume undefeated???????????????????

[Mr. Fantastic]

oscar did win 6 divisions..but floyd did 5 undefeated

Oscar did it while fighting ATGs.

[Pullcounter]

how many ATGs were around during floyd's time?