Which was the nastier beatdown?

[Lubutheimmortal]

Betweens Floyd Mayweather Jr's win over Arturo Gatti, or Manny Pacquiao's win over Oscar De La Hoya?


I'll go first with saying that I can't really pick one right out because both where total one sided victories for Pac & Floyd. You can consider several things to maybe find an answer such as which was the better comp (Gatti or Hoya) to thinking on who you believe dealt out the most damage (between Floyd or Manny).

Anyways like I said before I can't really flat out pick one, so I was wondering what everyone else's opinion was on the matter.

Thanks in advance for the replies!

[THe TRiNiTY]

Manny killing Oscar was the better beatdown.

Both losers were faded, and in both fights you had a size advantage. However, Manny was REALISTICALLY the smaller guy, regardless of weight. Oscar is a bigger person in life. Walks around heavier, taller, bigger overall build.

Not to mention that he made his OPPONENT give up, not his corner.

[savorduhflavor]

Mayweather vs. Corrales. That was difficult to watch.

[MANGLER]

Call it either way; Gatti musta gotten it worse cuz he was taken out in 6, or DLH got it worse since he endured 2 more rds of punishment than Gatti did before he was stopped. I'd say overall DLH got it worse, since he got his against a midget who he was supposed to decapitate.

[The Great Shark]

Hmm. DLH looked like Michelin Mans mexican baby after the fight, but I'd say PBF's beatdown on Gatti was nastier.

[SalSanchez]

Floyd vs Diego was a pure beatdown.How many times did chico went down? 4 or 5?

[Low Blow Armo]

The gatti beatdown was the worst I've seen. Then I saw him get even more ****ed up by Baldomir and I thought that was worse. Then I saw the beatdown he took in the hands of Alfonso Gomez, and I thought that was even worse.

[Lubutheimmortal]

Yea there are several things you can consider like Hoya being bigger and still getting whooped by the smaller guy.Gatti getting out of the fight in 6, where Hoya lasted 2 more. I thought it was a somewhat interesting thing to sit down and think about.

[Bhopreign]

Gatti's lasted longer.

[Lubutheimmortal]

The gatti beatdown was the worst I've seen. Then I saw him get even more ****ed up by Baldomir and I thought that was worse. Then I saw the beatdown he took in the hands of Alfonso Gomez, and I thought that was even worse.

Lol yea, poor Gatti.