Who is most overrated fighter today??

[Allucard]

So you have no problems with a 26 year old fighting pensioners, yet when a 36 year old does it, he becomes overrated.

As for "what the 26 has done (if not beaten) already" comment, I'd like to know where you got the idea that Dawson is 46-0, has had 21 world title defenses, held all four belts plus the ring belt at his original weight and then stepped up in weight to win the ring belt there as well.

Words really do fail me sometimes...



Calzaghe ruined him. Taylor just feasted on the remains.

Like Calzaghe ruins anyone lol. Bernard for instance. You lose. Kessler and Lacy are simply NOT talented enough. Why would a young Kessler all respect to the nords but why would he still be fighting in Denmark?! And Lacy, what's the deal losing to Taylor like that? These are young guys in their primes FAILING in boxing (in Kessler's case he avoids failing by NOT TRYING, which is a failure in any case). These are Calzaghe's best wins. Not enough.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Joe "I beat pensioners" Calzaghe

Absolutely. The slapper is waaaaaaaay overrated.

[Allucard]

So you have no problems with a 26 year old fighting pensioners, yet when a 36 year old does it, he becomes overrated.

As for "what the 26 has done (if not beaten) already" comment, I'd like to know where you got the idea that Dawson is 46-0, has had 21 world title defenses, held all four belts plus the ring belt at his original weight and then stepped up in weight to win the ring belt there as well.

Words really do fail me sometimes...



Calzaghe ruined him. Taylor just feasted on the remains.

Look at me, i have a world tittle in my backyard. I'll defending 2936 times vs my little brother. I'm so great. Write that down! 21 defenses!!!

[deemo]

margarito, he defeated cotto and now everyone thinks he is unbeatable. he is a tuff sob but i seen him almost lose to a one handed fighter and really had clottey winning. then he got beat by paul williams who most on here say is overrated.

[KESSLER]

Paul Williams.
Zab Judah.
Chad Dawson.

[Welter_Skelter]

I ll go with Paulie Malignaggi and Zab Judah.
Zab Judah still gets title fights based on KO over Spinks in 2005.He is going down to 140 and he wont do ****.Pauli Malignaggi in my opinion lost second Ndou fight and Ngoudjo fight and got killed by fattie Hatton.
Who do you pick??

Paul Williams
David Haye
James Toney (at heavyweight)
Kelly Pavlik
Lucien Bute
Zab Judah
Floyd Mayweather (accomplishment wise, Not talent wise)
Ricky Hatton

[J.R]

I love Calzaghe i really do but, people DO make him out to be better than he actually is. He's great, but still needs to shut a few people up. If he was 2 yrs younger i'd suggest a Hopkins Rematch, the maybe Froch and Dawson, then maybe he'll be 'rated' so to speak.

[x-PeROxiDE-x]

Like Calzaghe ruins anyone lol. Bernard for instance. You lose. Kessler and Lacy are simply NOT talented enough. Why would a young Kessler all respect to the nords but why would he still be fighting in Denmark?! And Lacy, what's the deal losing to Taylor like that? These are young guys in their primes FAILING in boxing (in Kessler's case he avoids failing by NOT TRYING, which is a failure in any case). These are Calzaghe's best wins. Not enough.

Are you really trying to tell me that Lacy is the same fighter now?

Calzaghe essentially ended Jeff's career.

I realise that might be painful for you to accept, but accept it you must, as it is the truth.

[Bushbaby]

Gamboa,this young guy has been down plenty of times,from shots that should'nt land.The minute he steps up to a fighter with the combination of skill and pop,who can counter,he is not getting off the canvas!!

[MANGLER]

Zab. I like the guy, but damn, it's been about 4 yrs since he did anything.