Better representative of the pfp#1 title. Floyd or Pac?

[larryx]

[QUOTE=Left Hook Tua;4559876]not biased.

it's true.

pacquiao was the underdog to oscar and should be the underdog to ricky.

floyd was the favorite against both.

maybe it's because pacquiao is smaller. maybe it's because floyd is so much better than pacquiao. either way......oscar and ricky are more dangerous to manny than the guys in his division while they were less dangerous to floyd than the top 2 guys in his division.

don't you think ricky and oscar has/had a better chance of beating manny than beating floyd?[/QUOTE]well damn i guess you're right.....

[Left Hook Tua]

Floyd first ever fight at Light Middle wa against the ring magazines no1 light middle... cut Floyd some slack, this was no easy match for him. De La Hoya weighed much more than Floyd on fight night. This fight is a credit to Floyd as it showed Floyds ring craft in avoiding Oscars left hook the whole night.

Although i agree Cotto and Margarito had a better chance at beating Floyd than Hatton. Im not too sure about Oscar. He had a significant weight advantage.

i give floyd credit for beating hatton and oscar. they were good wins.

as far as oscar......was he #1 at 154?

between his loss to mosley at 154 in 2003 and his loss to floyd in 2007 , oscar had 1 fight at 154.

that's 1 fight in 3 years at 154.

[larryx]

i give floyd credit for beating hatton and oscar. they were good wins.

as far as oscar......was he #1 at 154?

between his loss to mosley at 154 in 2003 and his loss to floyd in 2007 , oscar had 1 fight at 154.

that's 1 fight in 3 years at 154.

yea he was #1..thats what happens when you own the magazine

[Left Hook Tua]

well damn i guess you're right.....

i think you misunderstood that's why.

i wasn't saying manny was better than floyd by beating oscar and fighting hatton.

i said it was more dangerous and more risk to manny than to floyd.

floyd is bigger than pac and his style , skill and defense allows him to beat bigger guys.

guys that floyd would whoop easily would give manny a hard time.

[larryx]

i think you misunderstood that's why.

i wasn't saying manny was better than floyd by beating oscar and fighting hatton.

i said it was more dangerous and more risk to manny than to floyd.

floyd is bigger than pac and his style , skill and defense allows him to beat bigger guys.

guys that floyd would whoop easily would give manny a hard time.

so basically floyd is a victim of his own greatness????

[MANGLER]

Pac. PBF is more skilled, but Pac fights and don't dodge. He's humble and a lot easier to respect and like than PBF.

[Left Hook Tua]

yea he was #1..thats what happens when you own the magazine

for real? lol

i know he beat mayorga for mayorga's belt. that was enough to get #1?

i guess......well 154 was crappy after tito , oscar , winky and shane moved out and when vargas became shot.

[Left Hook Tua]

so basically floyd is a victim of his own greatness????

you can say that.

look at pac's win over diaz. diaz is a good fighter. he won his belt from santa cruz , santa cruz is no bum. but after pac schooled him everyone dismissed the win.

hell look at pac's delahoya win. if it was a close fight and he won by sd or late tko or something he'd get more credit than when he shut out oscar. now instead of saying how manny beat a much bigger opponent they say he beat a shot fighter.

[larryx]

for real? lol

i know he beat mayorga for mayorga's belt. that was enough to get #1.

i guess......well 154 was crappy after tito , oscar , winky and shane moved out and when vargas became shot.

hell he's still#3 at 154 according to the ring????go figure

[larryx]

you can say that.

look at pac's win over diaz. diaz is a good fighter. he won his belt from santa cruz , santa cruz is no bum. but after pac schooled him everyone dismissed the win.

hell look at pac's delahoya win. if it was a close fight and he won by sd or late tko or something he'd get more credit than when he shut out oscar. now instead of saying how manny beat a much bigger opponent they say he beat a shot fighter.

now that pacman is getting the spot light alot of haters will attack him also..aint it good to be on top